This decision brings
SNP policy on NATO into line with that of the Scottish Democratic
Alliance (SDA), which is to place a constitutional ban on all CBRN
weapons of mass destruction (not just nuclear ones) in Scotland, its
territorial waters and airspace, while seeking international
cooperation through NATO to safeguard Scotland's independence and
territorial integrity.
It is also in line
with the United Nations campaign to abolish all CBRN weapons
(chemical, biological, radiological and nuclear) once and for all.
This policy has already had considerable success in the cases of
chemical and biological devices, which are now being run down
worldwide, with remaining stocks being destroyed under UN
supervision.
The present situation
with nuclear weapons is less advanced , since the dozen or so states
that still retain them - against the fiercely expressed disapproval
of the rest of the international community - are doing so largely
for domestic political and not defensive reasons. Under present
circumstances they are completely useless as deterrents, even
against rogue states, because no government of a civilised state
would dream of incinerating an innocent and probably repressed
civilian population in order to exact revenge against their deluded
and malignant political, religious and military leadership.
Unfortunately,
nuclear weapons are still something of a national status symbol - at
least in the minds of some politicians and military leaders. The
United Nations has already made progress towards their abolition in
the form of a total ban on nuclear weapons testing, in order to halt
their further development. This has been a marked success to date,
even though a handful of states with nuclear facilities have not yet
ratified the relevant treaty (see
www.ctbto.org). US President Obama and Secretary of State
Clinton both have total abolition as their ultimate objective, but
the Senate is the stumbling block for the present. The Chinese are
waiting on a US move on the CTB Treaty, but the Russians signed and
ratified it right away.
We can be certain
that the SNP debate, and the voting figures, will have been noted at
NATO HQ as well as the foreign ministries of all its 50 member and
partner states. Only four of the NATO countries - the US, Russia, UK
and France - possess WMDs, and the other 46 show no ambition
whatsoever to acquire them. It is time for Scotland to join their
ranks.
Having worked for
decades in international affairs, I am better aware than most of how
lamentably ignorant Scotland is generally regarding the world in
which it will have to exist for all the foreseeable future - a world
that has changed so drastically within the past 20 years that it is
unrecognisable to anyone whose international experience is not up to
date.
The SNP, as a major
Scottish national institution, demonstrates that ignorance and
inexperience of international affairs to a marked degree, most
pronouncedly in its European policy, where it is decades behind the
times. It is learning, however slowly, and it is good to see that it
has now closed one major gap in its policy.
As the SDA's Security
and Defence policy points out, this is now a global issue and must
be organised on a basis of global cooperation. Even Europe is too
small nowadays, which is why NATO provides some of the most vital
support for the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime in respect
of anti-terrorist activities. Neither Scotland nor the UK can
possibly defend itself against all the modern threats and risks.
One final point. The
SNP policy takes no account of the world's largest security
institution, the 56-member Organisation for Security and Cooperation
in Europe. The OSCE, a Chapter VIII organisation under the United
Nations Charter, is the largest and most successful European
institution, but operates on a diplomatic basis, in cooperation with
the NATO military organisation in many a troubled situation. It is
the OSCE, and not the EU, that represents Europe at the United
Nations and reports on Europe to the Security Council. And it was
the OSCE, and not the EU, that stopped the Cold War and disarmed
Europe (the EU was not founded till after the end of the Cold War).
Independent Scotland
will have to join the OSCE, and the other major European
organisations (Council of Europe, UNECE), but beforehand it would be
no bad idea to run a course of education for its decision makers. I
am all in favour of stopping the world to let Scotland on, but the
first step to that end is to be clear on the true nature of the
world you aspire to join.