THE next minister was Anthony
Dow, A.M., a graduate of St. Andrews and a licentiate of the Presbytery of
Cupar, ordained minister of the parish, 26th September, 1723. He married
Ann, eldest daughter of Mr William Reid, minister of Dunning, and had a son
David, minister of Dron, and a daughter Jean, who married Mr Robert Trail,
minister of Panbride. He died on 25th August, 1772, aged 78, and in the
forty-ninth year of his ministry. It was the longest ministry of anyone
either before or after in the parish; and in many respects, as will be seen,
the most eventful. In the discharge of his duties he was very faithful, but,
owing to infirmity and loss of memory in his latter years, he was laid aside
from preaching; yet, it is said, that with the help of Mr Barclay, his
assistant, alongside as prompter, he continued to the last to officiate at
all the baptisms and marriages.
The elders in his time were,
in 1733, Alexander Picky man in Uppermill (Treasurer); Alexander Scott in
Nethermill; William Ferguson in Mains of Fettercairn; and James Clark in
Denstrath. The last named "joined the Independent faction in the village and
was deposed." In 1741, James Law in Mains of Balbegno; James Wallace in
Hillton of Dalladies; and James Niddrie in Fettercairn.
In 1742, David Low in
Fettercairn (Treasurer); David Wylie (smith) in Stankeye; and William
Christy in Stranosen. In 1748, David Carnegie, Robert Carnegie, and William
Valentine (in land of Arnhall); Robert Valentine in Denstrath; and John Law
in Mains of Drumhendry. And in 1765, John Kinloch in Uppermill; and James
Law, junr., in Caldcotes. In those days the
mendicant's badge.
office of elder was no
sinecure. Besides the oversight of the congregation, many duties had to be
performed. The care of the poor, the settling of quarrels between neighbours,
and the suppression of disorder, took up much time and attention. Local
incidents and details, however, may best be left over for a chapter on the
social customs and the condition of the people in the eighteenth century. Mr
Dow and his session introduced several changes. The first holding of a fast
day, for the yearly communion, was in 1727. The metal tokens for
communicants were first issued in 1725. Badges of metal or parchment and
bluegowns, as licenses to beg, were provided for the poor of the parish. The
last set of mendicants' badges in Fettercairn was issued in 1817.
Twenty-four of these, made of copper, were supplied to the Kirk Session at a
cost of Is. each, by Elizabeth Austin, merchant. The accompanying
illustration is taken off one now in possession of the Rev. William
Anderson.
In 1735 Mr Dow petitioned the
Presbytery to take steps towards allocating to him from the kirk lands of
the parish, a glebe of the full size allowed by law, the extent of his
glebe, including office and garden, being only two acres and half a rood.
The Presbytery discerned for four acres in addition "off a shade of land
called 'Allonagoin' (Weaponshaw field), on the estate of Fettercairn,
belonging to Colonel Straton in Old Montrose; between which shade and the
land set apart for the minister's grass there is nothing interjected save
ridges mortified to the schoolmaster of Fettercairn." By excam-bion in 1834,
these ridges are represented by a square piece of land in the south-east
corner of the glebe. Of Mr Dow's encounter with Davidson and his band some
account has already been given : but in Mr Cruickshank's "Navar and Lethnot,"
just published, a further account is given of James Davidson, the rebel
freebooter, who with his lawless band committed the raid on Fettercairn as
noticed in Chapter VII. Davidson had been a
soldier at the battle of Fontenoy, but deserted to the French, and joined
the Rebellion in Scotland. After its suppression he headed a band of
"outstanding rebels," made plundering attacks overnight on the houses of
several Presbyterian ministers and schoolmasters loyal to the Hanoverian
government, in the counties of Foifar, Kincardine and Aberdeen. They carried
off money and every article of value they could get hold of. For instance,
Mr Harper, schoolmaster of Durris, was robbed of £30 sterling. Davidson was
apprehended in Cortachy after he had committed two robberies there, and made
an attempt on the life of the minister, Mr Brown. The date of his execution
at Aberdeen was 1st July, 1748. The later years of Mr Dow's ministry became
times of trouble and excitement. John Barclay, A.M., son of a farmer in the
parish of Muthill, a licentiate of the Presbytery of Auchterarder (1759),
and assistant in Errol parish, became assistant to Mr Dow in 1763. In a
Biography of Mr Barclay, it is stated that he was of a fair and rather
florid complexion. He looked younger than he really was; and on account of
his youthful appearance, the people of Fettercairn were at first greatly
prejudiced against him. "But this was soon forgotten. His fervid manner, in
prayer especially, and at different parts of almost every sermon, riveted
the attention and impressed the minds of his audience to such a degree that
it was almost impossible to lose the memory of it. His popularity as a
preacher became so great at Fettercairn, that hardly anything of the kind
was to be met with in the history of the Church of Scotland. The parish
church, being an old-fashioned building, had rafters across. These were
crowded with hearers; the sashes of the windows were taken out to
accommodate the multitude that could not gain admittance. During the whole
period of his assistantship at Fettercairn he had regular hearers who
flocked to him from ten or twelve of the neighbouring parishes. He had a
most luxuriant fancy, and a great taste for poetry. His taste, however, was
not very correct, and he lacked sound judgment. . . . Besides his woiks in
prose, he published thousands of verses on religious subjects. He composed a
paraphrase of the whole Book of Psalms, which was partly published in 1766."
The reference to the "rafters of the kirk" in the above quotation recalls an
anecdote about the Kirk of Rerrick, in the stewartry of Kirkcudbright. Mr
Rouat had been the minister, and was appointed Professor of Church History
in the Univeraitv of Glasgow. At the first sacrament of his successor,
a'Miss Dunlop, afterwards Lady Wallace, coming to church rather early,
expressed her satisfaction to an old servant at seeing the church so
decently filled. "Madam," said the old man, "this is nothing to what I have
seen in Mr Rouat's time. I have heard the boogers (rafters) crackin* at sax
o'clock in the mornin'." "The boogers crackin'! What do you mean, James ?"
said Miss Dunlop. "Yes, Madam," continued James, "I have seen the fowk in
his time sittin' on the baulks o' the kirk like bykes o' bees."
By inculcating Antinomian
doctrines, Mr Barclay incurred the displeasure of the heritors and the
Presbytery. He nevertheless, with the concurrence of Mr Dow, petitioned for
ordination, and was refused on the ground that he had no cure of souls. The
Presbytery, moreover, by a majority had enjoined Mr Dow to dismiss his
assistant, because of the principles advanced in a book published by him. Mr
Dow replied that the press was free to any one to show whether the book
contained "dangerous and damnable principles"; that it was arbitrary and
unchristian to condemn a man unheard and not admonished; and that if he
dismissed Mr Barclay, another could not be got to visit the sick and
catechise the people. Whereupon Mr Barclay was summoned to appear before the
Presbytery and answer whether he was the author of a book, that had meantime
been examined by their committee, the title of the same being Rejoice
evermore; or, Christ all in all, an original publication, consisting of
spiritual songs collected from the Holy Scriptures, and several of the
Psalms, together with the whole Song of Solomon paraphrased, with three
discourses relative to these subjects, and subscribed John Barclay 1 He
answered " Yes." And whether he preached the doctrines contained in the book
? He did. To other thirty-one queries put, he craved time to reply. In due
time he sent his answers, as well as an apology and petition ; but the
Presbytery, after deliberation, considered them unsatisfactory, gave him a
new set of queries to elicit more direct and explicit answers. His answers
being only in part satisfactory, the Presbytery resolved to call him to
their bar to be censured; and that this resolution be intimated in the
church of Fettercairn.
These proceedings extended
over two years to the close of 1768. Mr Barclay continued to act as
assistant till the death of Mr Dow in August, 1772, but was no longer
allowed to officiate in the church. He applied to the Presbytery for a
certificate, and was refused. He appealed to the General Assembly, but they
dismissed the case in May, 1773. The people believed, and not without
reason, that the members of Presbytery were more or less prejudiced.
Petitions were presented to the heritors and to His Majesty George III. in
favour of Mr Barclay to be their minister. A volume recently published from
the State Paper Records contains a summary of the said petitions, as well as
a copy of a wonderfully worded letter to the Home Secretary. The letter and
summary run as follows:—
"12th October, 1772.
Alexander Wyllie to the Earl of Suffolk, entreating his Majesty to grant a
petition in favour qf Mr John Barclay, a gentleman to the liking of the
whole parishioners for 9 years past, to be minister of Fettercairn, as the
souls of the people in that parish are in hazard, as they think they cannot
attain happiness in a future state, unless they gitt the said Mr John
Barclay to be their minister.
"This awful circumstance,
with submission to your Lordship, i& a popular call to Mr Barclay to be
minister, and were a pity he should not be settled, in regard that there are
2500 examinable persons in the parish, old and young, who would fight for
his Majesty till their shoes were full of blood, upon getting Mr Barclay to
be their minister; and, if they are frustrated, the consequence is of very
great concern to such a numerous body of people who will obtain adherents in
the whole country around, and by that step of theirs, although deemed
irregular, unavoidably unforeseen disturbances, and the peace and quiet of
families, brought about in flame and riot and disorder the one against the
other may take place. And pray for what ? A minister. And as the numerous
body of well civilized people wants Mr Barclay, they ought by the law of Ood,
nature and nations to have him, as they are the only persons interested in
the settlement. The heritors may pretend that the balance of power is in
their hands with respect to the Establishment proposed to be observed in the
Church of Scotland. I say that thought of theirs ought to go for nought. And
the placing of a minister is to them nothing further than moonshine, and
serving by jobs one for another; and they laugh at our calamity because the
stipend is in the gift of our worthy sovereign."
Then follows the summary:—
"Mr Wyllie also affirms that
the heritors were not .only none of them resident in the parish, but none
members of the Communion of the Church of Scotland. He signs himself Agent
and Doer for the parishioners of Fettercairn Parish, and gives for address:
Alexander Wyllie of Penfield, notary public, at his lodgings in the city of
Brechin, N. Brittain."
Following this letter is a
petition to His Majesty to the same effect signed on behalf of the
parishioners by the said Alexander Wyllie, Robert Henderson, merchant, and
Alexander Hodge, farmer (Mains of Fasque).
"That petition states that,
in 1770, Mr Barclay having given great satisfaction during Mr Dow, the
pastor's, long sickness and infirmities, the parishioners, by the advice and
direction of the landed gentlemen, drew up and subscribed a petition to them
signifying their earnest desire to have Mr Barclay settled amongst them, and
they were then led to believe that the heritors would have applied for His
Majesty's consent to Mr Barclay's settlement; but from some cause unknown,
this application was never made. The late minister was also greatly desirous
of seeing the parish comfortably settled before his death, and strongly
recommended Mr Barclay. The original petition to the heritors, referred to
in the preceding petition, with a great number of signatures, is also with
these papers."
Upon the refusal of these
petitions, the deliverance of the General Assembly and the presentation of
the Rev. Robert Foote to the church and parish, the people moved off in a
body with Mr Barclay and worshipped for a time in a barn at Meikleha\ The
church at Sauchieburn was soon after built and occupied by a congregation of
ten or twelve hundred members, but Mr Barclay left in the end of the same
year (1773) to be ordained to a congregation in Newcastle. He continued
zealously and ardently to promulgate his views, and succeeded in forming
congregations in Edinburgh, Glasgow, Crieff, Kirkcaldy, Arbroath, Montrose,
Brechin, and other places. He died in Edinburgh on the 29th of July, 1798,
aged 64; was interred in the Old Calton Churchyard, where a monument was
afterwards erected to his memory. The sect he formed were called "Bereans"
(from Acts xvii. 11), and the name was self-imposed. Their leading tenet was
to reject established articles and confessions of faith, holding the Bible
to be the only certain rule of faith and manners. They also held that all
who possessed a full assurance of their own salvation were perfectly safe;
but they did not pretend to found that assurance on the conformity of their
actions to the rules of Christianity.
A Mr James Macrae,
grandfather of the Rev. David Macrae, late of Dundee, was appointed in 1774
to the charge of Sauchieburn; and he laboured faithfully, not only as the
minister, but very successfully as the teacher of a week-day school for the
youth of the district. Some of his pupils, in later years as old people
known to the writer, were wont fondly to relate their reminiscences of Mr
Macrae and his school at Sauchieburn.
In course of time, and very
much owing to the excellent ministrations of Mr Foote, the Berean hody
dwindled, and many of the people returned to the church. Still, a few lay
preachers kept up weekly meetings in their own private houses. One of these
was Anthony Glen, who used to tell that if not allowed to preach he would
rive. His discourses were homely. The following is a fair sample of his
oratory, when discoursing on the love of money. "Fowk wud do a* things for
the love o' money. They wud gang ower seas, an' into pairts whar naehody
kenn'd them, an' a' for the greed o' gain. Their grace afore meat an* After
meat, an' their prayers at a' time, was bawbees-Amen."
William Taylor, carrier, Kaw
of Balmain, was the last of the Berean preachers. After walking five miles
he officiated regularly, along with others, at the Sunday meetings in
Laurencekirk. He survived his colleagues; and with the last of them, a John
Todd, farmer at Buttery-braes, divided the duties of the Sunday, with a
remark such as, "Noo, John, ye'll come up and lat 's see daylight through
the Komans." At Yule time John always warned his audience, "My frien's,
beware o' cairds an' dice and that bewitchin' thing the totum." The chapel,
a small building, stood in what is now known as "Berean Lane." About 1840
the services there ceased, and William conducted Sunday meetings in his own
barn at Balmain, to which not a few repaired to take stock of his sayings.
On one occasion his father, a frail old man, acted as precentor, and
according to the custom when books were scarce, he tried to recite line by
line to be sung. But William, not pleased with the effort, sharply
interposed, and addressing him in the same musical tone, said, "Ye stupid
eediot, lat's see the buik, an' I'll sing mysel'." In the course of his
ministrations in the barn, William on one occasion worked himself up to a
great flight of oratory, some of his illustrations being quite unrepeatable.
Once he quite excelled himself. "Put on the shield of faith," ma friends;
"Arm yourselves wf the gospel"; and imitating the charging of the old muzzle
loader of the time, he exclaimed, "Ram it home to the breech, ma dear
brethren, once again to the breech "; then, as it were shouldering and
directing the gun, he passionately exclaimed, "And we'll shoot the devil
like a rotten i' the crap o' the wa' wi' the gun o' salvation. Amen."
About 1834 two gentlemen,
acting on a Government Commission anent Church statistics, called upon Mr
Whyte, the parish minister, and after getting from him what they required,
he mentioned the name of William Taylor, the Berean preacher. They went and
found him at the plough. The following colloquy took place: "You are a
preacher, we believe."—"Maybe I am."—"What stipend do you receive?"—"Ou
nae muckle."—"But how much?"— " Ou ! maybe thirty shilling."—"Have you any
other occupation ?"—" Ou! I gang to Montrose wi' the cairt, and sometimes I
fell swine." He died in the early sixties. The Bereans, in the place where
they had their origin, are now extinct. The last of the sect in Laurencekirk
were two old women, and when one of them died the other feelingly remarked,
"Wae 's me! when I gang too the Bereans 'll be 'clean licket aff!" Whatever
may be said of Mr Barclay and the Bereans, it must be admitted that good
effects were produced, inasmuch as devout feelings and orderly conduct took
the place of many evil habits.