WEEK BEGINNING MONDAY 15th JANUARY
2007
Always a good start
to the week when you get to go along to a Primary School; St. Mark’s
in Hamilton this Monday morning where the primary 7 pupils had
prepared a ‘Question Time’ event. Pupils on the Panel first,
followed by myself and the local SSP and Tory MSP. The wee lad who
was doing his ‘Dimbleby’ stint really had it off pat – no nonsense
and very fair in his allocation of time. Well done St. Mark’s! We
then had tea with the Pupil Council – a rep from each class who
discuss what’s happening in the school and plans for the future. All
very organised and impressive.
Very different
company in the afternoon when I sped through to Edinburgh to meet
with Sir Peter Ricketts, UK Permanent Under-Secretary and Head of
the Diplomatic Service (“he was very nice”, I said to Calum; “of
course he was”, says the bold boy, “he is heid diplomat, after
all!”; yeh, right enough). It was an enjoyable meeting though, and
we discussed the Foreign Office’s relationship with MSPs and members
of the Europe and External Relations Committee, and how we might
improve this in the future. Not that it’s a bad relationship
particularly – I have always found the Diplomatic and Foreign Office
staff helpful generally, it’s just difficult sometimes to know who
to go to for information. It’s interesting, the way that different
UK departments deal with us here in Scotland’s Parliament: Although
they deal with ‘reserved matters’ I’ve always found the
International Development Department and the Foreign Office very
approachable whilst the Home Office, in relation to Immigration and
Asylum issues, is extremely unhelpful. I suppose it depends a lot on
who’s heading up the operation – John Reid MP at the Home Office; I
guess that answers that point!
Talking of the Home
Office I found myself shouting at my car radio last week when I
heard John Reid’s predecessor, David Blunkett, criticising the
police investigation into the ‘cash for honours’ scandal because
they’d arrested a Labour aide (Ruth Turner) at her home at 6.30 in
the morning on suspicion of perverting the course of justice. He
reckoned this was ridiculous, she wasn’t a criminal after all; so,
what about the practice of dawn raids on innocent asylum-seeking
families then Mr. Blunkett? You fully supported that when you were
Home Secretary, and still do as far as I know – their hypocrisy is
staggering. They basically think that they and their pals are above
the law of their land.
Europe committee on
Tuesday afternoon – taking evidence still on the ‘Transposition of
European Directives’, and some interesting perspectives on how the
Scottish Executive looks after Scotland’s interests in Europe. For
example – some direct quotes:
Andy Robertson (NFU
Scotland):” … Engagement through the Executive is minimal. … … …
My experience is that I can get more direct access to officials in
Brussels by working through the NFUS than I could in my previous
existence as a Scottish Executive official … …”
James Withers (NFU
Scotland): “I add that, in my
experience since devolution the Executive has struggled to find its
feet in dealing with Europe. there is a lack of clarity about where
the boundaries are. … … … We sometimes find ourselves in the
difficult position of feeling that we are doing the Executive’s job
for it. We run to the Commission to find out the parameters within
which we are working and then feed the message back to the
Executive.”
Readers can form
their own conclusions as to whether the Labour/LibDem coalition is
truly looking after Scotland’s interests in Europe. Of course, since
our meeting there have been further developments on this question,
but that’s next week’s diary!
Busy Chamber days on
Wednesday and Thursday with introductory debates on proposed
legislation – The Protection of Vulnerable Groups (Scotland) Bill,
the Prostitution (Public Places) (Scotland) Bill, and the final
debate on the ‘Criminal proceedings etc. (Reform) (Scotland) Bill.
And then, on Thursday evening, a debate sponsored by yours truly on
the Scottish Council for Single Homeless initiative for pupils in
fourth and fifth year at school – HomeSmart. I was really pleased to
be able to secure a slot for debate for this really important
campaign. I won’t reproduce the whole debate here, but my own
contribution at the start outlines the initiative and if anyone
wants to read more about it, you can log on to the SCSH website at
http://www.scsh.co.uk/
Linda Fabiani (Central
Scotland) (SNP): It is a mark of how
important the subject is that members have agreed to bring the
debate forward by an hour. I declare an interest, as a fellow of the
Chartered Institute of Housing. That membership exists from the days
before I was elected, when I worked in housing associations. I have
experience of dealing with homelessness applications from a service
provider's point of view, as well as from a politician's. I think
that I speak for most housing professionals when I say that there
was always a particular poignancy when a young person presented as
homeless—I felt helpless and that I could not be of real assistance
to them.
My experience has given me a
perspective on the issue that underpins my belief in the absolute
necessity of tackling homelessness and seeking to eliminate it as
far as is humanly possible. Part of that task is the provision of
suitable and affordable housing, including owner-occupied and social
rented housing. We all know that that is an issue in many areas. In
East Kilbride, where I live, it is a particular problem. A major
part of the task must also be helping people to avoid homelessness
in the first place. That is the main thrust of the home smart
campaign, which seeks to ensure that every fourth-year pupil in our
schools knows that help and advice is available.
Great credit should be given
to the Scottish Council for Single Homeless for creating the
campaign. Its importance is underlined by the statistics on youth
homelessness. In 2005-06, 19,400 young people between the ages of 16
and 24 turned to their local authority because they had nowhere safe
and secure to stay. That is a rise of almost 4,000 since 1999. If we
consider the figures for 16 and 17-year-olds, in 2005-06 more than
4,300 young people turned to their local authority. While few
fourth-year pupils are likely to think that homelessness will affect
them personally, the figures tell a different story.
There is a significant,
worsening problem with youth homelessness that we owe it to
Scotland's youngsters to address. With 3 per cent of young people in
Scotland reporting as homeless each year, we cannot afford to turn
away and hope that the problem resolves itself. We should be
grateful to the Scottish Council for Single Homeless for the work
that it has been doing and we should embrace the home smart campaign
as an extremely worthwhile endeavour.
The council's idea for the
campaign is simple, but appears to offer the right kind of help.
Rather than waiting until the young person strikes out on their own,
obtains a tenancy, then fails to maintain it and ends up homeless,
it has taken the sensible step of taking the message into schools.
The information in learning packs allows teachers and pupils to
consider the issues that often arise with tenancies and young
people, and to consider how they might avoid the pitfalls that have
befallen so many in the past. As well as facilitating discussion,
the packs offer sensible advice, including, for example, advice
about how to ensure that the behaviour of one's friends does not
affect one's tenancy. That seems fairly straightforward to those of
us sitting here, but one of the major problems that young tenants
have is in controlling their home environment and not letting it
turn into a community centre for their friends.
I wish to make it clear,
though, that the campaign is not an entirely new venture for the
Scottish Council for Single Homeless. The ‘I'm offski!’ learning
materials were first produced in 1988 and have won awards. However,
home smart goes even further. The experience of the organisation
over many years is illustrated by its developing and innovatory
campaigns. It will soon produce an evaluation toolkit to measure the
success of the campaign—I am sure that it will be very successful.
Getting pupils to think about the issues while they are still in the
fourth year of secondary school will ensure that the information is
embedded and that they know that support and advice is available.
Targeting the campaign at
fourth years is important—I believe that it is the optimum age group
to target. It is the age group that is perhaps desperate to leave
home for negative reasons. It is an age group that may have a
rose-tinted view of how one can strike out on one's own and be a
success. Many young people who are at a stage in their lives when
they should be building for the future can struggle to find the
resources just to survive. Surviving day by day instead of planning
for their future leaves them vulnerable to all sorts of outside
influences. Home smart is about trying to stop that happening.
It is hard to judge how many
pupils have so far been exposed to the materials produced by the
council, but around a third of our mainstream schools have indicated
a strong interest. That points towards a possible 20,000 pupils. I
make particular mention of John Ogilvie High School and Strathaven
Academy, schools in central Scotland that I know well for their
openness to new ideas and that have responded positively to the
Scottish Council for Single Homeless.
Roseanna Cunningham (Perth) (SNP):
Understandably, the member is mostly focused on
central region, but is she aware that the interest of schools in
home smart goes far beyond it? Indeed, a primary school in my
constituency—Balnacraig school in Perth—has won a prize in the
competition. Does she agree that that school should also be
commended?
Linda Fabiani:
Absolutely. I am happy to commend Balnacraig
school in Perth. That underlines the fact that the campaign is
national.
As I said, every mainstream
school has received a pack, and any special needs and residential
schools that have expressed an interest have received one too.
I congratulate and commend the
Scottish Council for Single Homeless for the work of home smart. I
also want to thank Lovell, the housing developer that has sponsored
the campaign and provided the prize for the recent draw. If the
campaign has ensured that pupils know that there are people and
organisations to which they can turn for help, and if it has
encouraged those pupils to think about the issues and appreciate the
challenges and difficulties that leaving home presents, the campaign
is worthy of congratulation and encouragement. As I said earlier,
more than a third of all homeless applications are from people
between the ages of 16 and 24.
Scotland's politicians should
be working towards ending the scourge of homelessness. Each of us in
the chamber should be humbled that the problem has still not been
turned around eight years after devolution, despite the good
intentions of us all. That perhaps indicates a need for more
positive action on the part of Scotland's politicians, a more
proactive agenda on youth homelessness and a greater encouragement
of the work done by organisations such as the Scottish Council for
Single Homeless.
And so to Friday.
Looking back over the week above it looks as if I wasn’t doing much,
and certainly I did have a couple of early nights for a change, but
then there was Friday! Up to Dornoch to do the Toast to Scotland at
the Tain SNP Burns Supper. A long way to go but a great time was
had, even though I had to get the early train from Inverness the
next morning. I don't get up to the Highlands enough these days - so
many friends there and so many beautiful places still to see.
The week started with
enjoyment, and finished with some more – the 50th
Anniversary of the Trefoil Guild in East Kilbride, celebrated with a
lunch, some speeches, and some chat. The Trefoil Guild comprises
ladies (men are allowed but none have applied!) who care about the
Guiding Movement and want to keep an involvement – most, but not
all, have been Guides or Guiders themselves. Even though I admitted
I was never a Brownie or a Guide, they assure me I can join the
Trefoil Guild; and even when I admitted I’d been in the Girls
Brigade for all of around three months (before I got in big trouble
for howking up my skirt to a mini during the parade), they still let
me be a Guiding Ambassador – gracious ladies all of them!
Back next week.
Linda Fabiani
22.1.07