Week beginning Monday March 21st
Constituency day – checking in with Davie to make
sure that between us we’re covering all the case work. Housing (lack
of!) features large again this week in East Kilbride. One case that
particularly got to us today was about a family living in a private
rented house with the lease about to expire. One of the parents and
two of the children have disabilities – in one case a very serious
illness needing a great deal of rest and care. We had hoped that the
Council would be able to help a family like this, but the answer came
back today that no offer in the near future likely because of the
shortage of housing in the town. Their only option for a council house
is to move out of East Kilbride, away from the hospital they use and
from the family and friends who give them support. Sometimes I just
feel like I’m hitting my head off a brick wall with this stuff, and if
I feel like this, goodness knows how it feels to be the family
involved.
I remember when I moved to work in East Kilbride in
1994. The New Town Development Corporation was winding down, social
housing was being transferred to the local authority and the local
housing association had started up, some very far sighted residents
believing that a stock of good, rented housing had to be maintained in
the town and not subject to the Right to Buy legislation. The
Development Corporation had operated a fairly aggressive sales policy
and much of the rented stock was gone. It was ‘the done thing’ in East
Kilbride to wait your turn for a house and then almost immediately buy
it at discount – we now of course have the legacy of this in the town
– private landlords letting out ex-Development Corporation properties
at rents matching the highest levels of Housing Benefit available and
beyond. I was the first member of staff at the Housing Association and
we faced a lot of opposition from all sides – it was hard work for the
voluntary Management Committee, but they stuck with it and by the time
I left in 1999 we had a stock of over 300 properties, all for social
rent, and protected from the Right to Buy policy.
And then, lo and behold, the Labour Party decided
to extend the Right to Buy – who would have believed it! It’s been
delayed until 2012, but East Kilbride Housing Association, like so
many others, will from that time start to lose the good, rented
housing stock that local residents fought to preserve. It’s not too
late yet though for that ridiculous decision to be overturned, and I
for one raise the Right to Buy issue at every opportunity – we hear
lots of fine words about how the RTB doesn’t actually mean that the
house itself is lost to the market; aye right, tell the family in East
Kilbride who have to move outwith the town where their child is in
hospital about the macro-economics of housing supply and demand, and
they’ll tell you that the RTB has had its day and should have been
stopped years ago.
Standards Committee Tuesday morning and a meeting
with the Standards Commissioner. This is the chap to whom complaints
about MSPs are made. The subject under discussion today was about how
to deal with malicious, vexatious, repeat complaints etc. and the
Commissioner wants the Committee to lay out the ground rules as to
whether a complaint to his office is admissable or not. We heard his
views and will discuss in full at the next meeting, but I can’t help
feeling that this chap is supposed to be independent and that his
independence could be compromised or, often just as importantly,
perceived as compromised, if MSPs become too much involved. Any
"anorak" amongst readers can check the Official Report in full on the
Parliament website!
Trustees Meeting at Just World Partners in the
afternoon – we’re still going through the mill with European funding
etc. and I really can’t say much just now until we’re sorted out, but
I’m becoming more and more frustrated with bureaucratic delays and the
refusal of anyone with clout to at least try to help us, either in
Brussels, in Latin America or indeed here in Scotland. Alyn Smith MEP
at the Brussels end is doing his best, and is rapidly becoming as
frustrated as me. When the organisation has come through this
difficulty and is back on an even keel, Alyn and I really do want to
do some proper research into how the European Community overseas
development funding actually works. The Scottish Executive has also
said that part of their international development strategy will be to
capacity-build and assist small Scottish based organisations, so I
must get started on teasing out exactly what that means too, as I
can’t even get them to speak to me about Just World Partners and the
difficulty of dealing with the EU!
I’ve just got back from the SNP Group Meeting where
we heard, amongst other things, the Public Services Ombudsman tell us
about how her job is panning out – the previous Ombudsman offices, eg
Local Government, Housing Association, NHS etc., have been amalgamated
over the last couple of years. The presentation was interesting and
informative, and it set me thinking again about the discussion with
the Standards Commissioner earlier in the day. Again, it’s about
perception, and the public should not be given the impression that
complaints about MSPs are treated any differently from complaints
about any other public servant. I did ask the Committee clerks after
the Standards Committee Meeting to check out under what directions the
office of the Public Services Ombudsman makes decisions about validity
of complaints.
Well, heading home now to watch the last episode of
The Gathering Place, the documentary about the Holyrood Project.
Roseanna and Rob accompanying me again and my turn to buy the
carry-out food – Chinese I think.
Well it’s Thursday night now and I’m in the office
in Edinburgh. Yes, I know I’ve skipped Wednesday, but actually, I
really did skip Wednesday: awful not well, but I’m sure details are
not required. One thing that particularly disappointed me though was
that I was supposed to be at the theatre last night to see 7:84
Theatre Company’s adaptation of Christopher Brookmyre’s novel "Boiling
a Frog". I was so looking forward to it because the book was smashing
– the tickets did get used though and seemingly I missed a great
performance. One of the thrills on the day of the Parliament opening
last year was meeting Christopher Brookmyre and showing him round my
office; my wee brother was really jealous when I told him because
Chris has been his favourite author for some time now. Of course, I
name drop at every opportunity.
I managed to get home to Strathaven last night
because this morning we had a Question Time at Strathaven Academy. It
was organised by the Fifth year students and was really well put
together with probing questions on current topics - school
lunches/childhood obesity, whether sexual orientation should have any
bearing on employment opportunities, whether proposed anti-terrorism
legislation is an infringement of human rights. It was over far too
quickly and I would like to have heard more views from the students
themselves.
I didn’t get back to Edinburgh this afternoon until
after 2.00 pm so I’m afraid I missed Question Time. Just working away
here, ploughing through the emails, answering letters, making phone
calls. That’s what my day is going to be tomorrow too. Tomorrow is
Good Friday so I’ve got no constituency visits arranged – Morag and I
are going to have a big clearout day, and Calum is going to stay well
out of the way in case he ends up bagged and recycled.
I’ve been getting asked all day how I felt about
"The Gathering Place" now that all four episodes have been shown. It
is difficult to be objective about it as a piece of film-making
because the project itself took up so much of my time over a period of
four years – the memories came flooding back with every scene. Much of
the criticism of the documentary that I’ve read and heard is that it
missed out so much that was critical – the selection of the site, the
method of contract procurement, the views of Donald Dewar, but I do
know that filming didn’t actually begin until 1999 and as has been
well documented elsewhere, all the big decisions were taken prior to
our Parliament being elected.
I guess many folk were looking for a political
piece of television whilst the programme was actually a
fly-on-the-wall view of what it was like to try to build a parliament,
and that to me was captured rather well; the worries, the
frustrations, the arguments, the huffs, the tantrums, but also the
fun, the people I met during the process, and overall the joy of
seeing our parliamentary complex come together at last at the bottom
of Edinburgh’s Royal Mile. One of the questions asked of some of the
key-players at the end of the programme was "would you do it again?"
Well, I would, but in the words of the old saw "if I was trying to get
there I wouldn’t start from here". "The Gathering Place" being shown
is like ‘the end’ for me, the closing chapter, and what I do have to
do now though is write down my own version of events for posterity
(some of it for private reading only!).
On a serious note, one of the things that jumped
out at me in the last episode was during the coverage of the
announcement of the Fraser Inquiry by the First Minister. Mr.
McConnell said quite clearly that he was holding this Inquiry because
"lessons had to be learned". Well, Lord Fraser had two remits – one,
to investigate the project, and two, to make recommendations about
future public procurement. I wrote to Lord Fraser recently about the
second part of his remit and the response was basically that this
wouldn’t be fulfilled! Not good enough – I’ve written to the First
Minister for his view on this and will shortly be meeting the Fraser
Inquiry team again. I’ll keep you up-to-date.
Well, Sunday night and boy do I feel
self-righteous. On Friday I did as I promised myself. Spent the day in
Edinburgh - tidy office, tidy cupboards, tidy drawers, all
correspondence and emails up-to-date. I’ll be out of the parliamentary
office for most of the next two weeks you see because it’s
Parliamentary recess. Time to catch up with community visits, research
and writing, and of course a bit of campaigning for the forthcoming
general election. I’ve even tidied up my office in the house and
sitting here typing with a clear desk having dealt with the weekend
emails. One of those attached a letter I was happy to add my signature
to; a letter to Tony Blair asking him not to support the US Nomination
of Paul Wolfowitz as President of the World Bank. The Observer
Newspaper reports today that some of the Cabinet members are not at
all happy that Blair is endorsing this man, and neither should they
be. This is the US Deputy Defence Secretary who actively promoted war
with Iraq, and the same man who as Ambassador to Indonesia did nothing
to stop the illegal occupation of East Timor which resulted in the
deaths of over 200,000 people. Surely when we’re hearing all the fine
talk about how we’re going to be in the forefront of international
development, and promoting human rights and democracy then we should
not be actively supporting such a nomination.
I’ve just been reminded it’s Easter Sunday, because
my favourite girl has just telephoned, all the way from Toronto,
Canada. I actually have more family in Canada than I do here at home –
five of my mum’s sisters emigrated, the first marrying a Canadian
soldier just after the War, and the last moving out there as a child
when my granny died in 1965. Monica is the 7 year old daughter of my
wee cousin James, so I think that makes her my
first-cousin-once-removed? Easter last year I was in Toronto with them
all, and I really do wish I was heading there again. Maybe summertime,
we’ll see.
Meanwhile, Peaceful Easter, I’ll write again on 11th
April.
Linda Fabiani
18.2.05