POLITICIANS have widely
differed with regard to the wisdom of enlightening the poor of a country
by education. Upon such a subject men of plain understandings would
naturally wonder that any variance of opinion could arise. They would
conceive that he who prefers darkness to light, who thinks that the
common people are most likely to advance the ends of their creation,
that they would be more loyal, more brave, and more virtuous, by
continuing in a state of ignorance and stupidity, would, by a parity of
reasoning, insist that the blind were the most likely to move with
certainty, and the crippled with vigour. But a distempered prejudice
still maintains that to illumine the head is to extinguish the heart;
that ii the humble are taught reading, writing, and a little useful
arithmetic, they will soon fancy themselves under the influence of
inspiration, and feel as if they had been intended for some high
destiny; that they will desert or disgrace the station of life allotted
to them by Providence and perish upon the dunghill as vagabonds, or by
the gallows as forgers. The poor of Scotland seem to have decided this
important question; they can read, and yet are loyal; they can write,
and yet are honest ; they can calculate, and yet are virtuous. By the
wise and salutary diffusion of education, particularly in parts which
appear to be impenetrable -to civilization, upon the sides of frightful
mountains, or in dismal glens seldom visited by the rays of Heaven, the
astonished and admiring traveller beholds a spectacle at once gratifying
and affecting. In a hut of branches and sods, when the hour of labour is
over, the young, enlightened by those, institutions which do honour to
human nature, are seen instructing those who are younger, or consoling
the last hours of venerable and sightless age by reading aloud the
Scriptures, or some pious book, printed in their own language; yet in
this sorry dwelling the benighted traveller may rest in safety amid the
howling storm; not a hand will be extended to him but in kindness, not a
voice will be raised but to charm his ear with the: song of other times,
or, if he understands the language, to store his mind with the wild,
romantic, and beautiful effusions of the Gaelic Muse.
It is equally singular and true that one can scarcely meet with a poor
man in any part of Scotland, who is not possessed of the knowledge
particularized in the commencement of this chapter, and to this he
frequently adds a little acquaintance with 'Latin. The results of this
system of education, which I shall briefly explain, are of the most
beneficent nature. If the poor remain at home, their deportment is
sedate, upright, and orderly ; if they attempt their fortunes in other
countries, they bear with them a superior understanding, and a knowledge
sharpened by poverty, which enables them to do honour to any situation,
and frequently to improve those arts, studies, and pursuits by which the
power, prosperity, and character of a country, are at once extended and
secured.
The emigration of the humbler classes of the Scotch is a subject of
frequent remark. Poor, but cultivated, they quit their native country in
the pursuit of fortune in other climes not more congenial to merit, but
more m want of talent, and better capable of rewarding it. How happy is
it that we live in an age and under a constitution which are propitious
to genius, under which humility of origin presents no insurmountable
barrier to the advancement of any one, y/ho, to intellect, unites
integrity, industry, and prudence.
In the fair pursuit of fortune they spread themselves in the most remote
regions of the earth. The celebrated Field-Marshal Keith, who, on
account of his having joined King James’s party in the old rebellion,
when he was about eighteen or nineteen years old, at the instigation of
his mother, after the battle of Sheriff-muir was obliged to escape to
France, and who afterwards bad a great share in the revolution which
raised Elizabeth the daughter of Peter the Great, to the throne of all
the Russias, and was afterwards the chief counsellor and companion of
the King of Prussia, is said to have related the following anecdote,
illustrative of the erratic disposition of the Scotch :— Being sent upon
an important mission to a Turkish officer of high rank, he was received
with all the honours and solemnities usual upon such occasions in the
east, and which so much encumber and procrastinate the issue of matters
of business. The Turk, to his surprise, seemed to feel as he did, a wish
to terminate their negotiation as speedily as possible : and upon his
learning that the Marshal spoke French, a language with which he too was
acquainted, he proposed dismissing their respective attendants, and
concluding the objects of their interview in privacy, which the Marshal
acceded to. A§ soon as the retinues of both these, personages had
retired, the Turk, to the utter astonishment of the Marshal, walked up
to him, and in broad Scotch said, "Weel, man, when was ye last at
Aberdeen?” On an explanation, which immediately followed this
extraordinary interrogatory, it appeared that this eastern chief was no
other than the son of a Scottish peasant, who remembered to have seen
Marshal Keith in Aberdeenshire, and who, in the pursuit of ameliorating
his condition, had wandered into Turkey, where by his good conduct he
had raised himself to Asiatic honours.
The same enterprising spirit has led them to colonize where one might
naturally suppose only the most powerful inducements of rapid
accumulation of riches could have attracted them. A number of Scotchmen
have for the last four years bedn settled on the mountains of Caucasus,
to whom his Imperial Majesty of Russia has granted, with that noble
liberality which always characterises his mind, a charter of
extraordinary rights and privileges, by which, in order to induce them
to extend their trade and manufactures in a district thinly peopled, and
bordering on the territories of many uncivilized tribes of Mahometans
and Heathens, they are placed on the same footing with the Evangelical
Society of Sarepta. His Majesty secures to them the perpetual possession
of ample allotments of land, as near as possible to the village which
they have founded and they are exempted from a variety of imposts. The
free exercise of their religion is confirmed to them ; and the
administration of their internal affairs is for ever vested in a chief
magistrate to be chosen amongst themselves, who is authorized to admit
as settlers amongst them every description of Mahometans and Heathens,
being freemen, and taking the oath of allegiance to his Imperial
Majesty.
Why has the Irish peasantry been so frequently rendered the object of an
angry policy? a peasantry derived from the same stock as the Scotch,
speaking the same language, whose customs and manners were originally
the same, and whose natural talents are, to an extraordinary degree,
strong and vivacious ? -why, but for the want of the same benign spirit
of instruction? Were any one who had visited Ireland to make their
amelioration the subject of his pen, I am persuaded that the conclusion
of all his reasoning would be, education ‘without proselytism.
Let us compare, by the assistance of a venerable author, the present
with the past condition of the Scottish peasantry. In the year 1698,
that illustrious Caledonian patriot, Andrew Fletcher, of Saltoun, who so
nobly declared that he would readily lose his life to save his country,
and would not do a base thing to serve it, tells us, "There are at this
day in Scotland two hundred thousand people begging from door to door;
and though the number of them be perhaps double to what it was formerly,
by reason of this present great distress, (a famine then prevailed), yet
in all times there have been about one hundred thousand of these
vagabonds, who have lived without any regard or subjection either to the
laws of the land or even those, of God and Nature; fathers incestuously
accompanying with their own daughters, the son with the mother, and the
brother with the sister. No magistrate ever could discover that they had
been baptized, or in what way one in a hundred went out of the world.
They are frequently guilty of robbery, and sometimes of murder. In years
of plenty many thousands of them meet together in the mountains, there
they feast and riot for many days; and at country weddings, markets,
burials, and on other public occasions, they are to be seen, both men
and women, perpetually drunk, cursing, blaspheming, and fighting
together.”
These dreadful evils were not mowed down by the sword, they were not
exterminated by ferocious penal laws; they were put to the blush by the
mild and salutary precepts of mental illumination, the light of which
they could not encounter, and withdrew forever from' its presence. This
system of education gives to the manner of a low Scotchman an air of
sedateness, acuteness, and consideration, which I have never witnessed
in the same class in any other country. A low Irishman frequently shapes
his answer by a quick and often erroneous anticipation, before the
question propounded is half finished. A Scotchman hears you without
interruption, and, after a pause of reflection, conveys a firm, modest,
and generally a luminous answer. So strong is the thirst for knowledge
amongst the lower orders in Scotland, that small farmers and petty
tradesmen are known to form themselves into literary societies ; and it
is related, upon authority, that the workmen in the lead mines of the
Earl of Hopetoun, at Lead-hills, have a common library supported by
contribution, containing several thousand volumes. These people work
only six hours, and therefore have time to gratify this extraordinary
passion for literature.
The philanthropic and political reader will, I am sure, be gratified
with a brief account of the enlightened system by which these admirable
traits in the Scottish character are effected. Parish schools were
erected by an Act of Parliament of Scotland, passed in 1646, which
enacted that a school should be established in every parish in Scotland,
for the express purpose of educating the poor ; it obliges the heritors
and ministers of each parish to meet and assess the several heritors
with the requisite sum for building a schoolhouse, and to elect a
schoolmaster, and modify a salary for him in all time to come, The
salary is ordered not to be under one hundred nor above two hundred
merks, that is, not under 5l. 11sj 1˝d. nor above 11l. 2s.
3d. and the assessment is to be laid on the land in the same proportion
as it is rated for the support of the clergy, and as it regulates the
payment of the land tax's. But in case the heritors of any parish, or
the majority of them, shall fail to discharge this duty, then the
persons forming what is called the Committee of Supply of the County
(consisting of the principal landholders) or any five of them, are
authorised by the statute to impose the assessment instead of them, on
the representation of the presbytery in which the parish is situated. To
secure the choice of a proper teacher, the right of election on the part
of the heritors, by a statute passed in 1693, chap. 22, is made subject
to the review and control of the presbytery of the district, who have a
right to examine the person proposed as to his qualifications as a
teacher, and as to his proper deportment in office, when settled in it
This election on the part of the heritors is therefore only a
presentment of a person for the approbation of the presbytery. The
statute of 1646 was repealed on the accession of Charles II. in 1660, on
account of its having been passed during the Commonwealth, and lay
dormant until after the Revolution, when it was re-enacted by the
Scottish parliament in the same form, and remains in force to this hour.
All this was excellent; but the income of the schoolmaster, fixed by the
provisions of the act, and arising also from the compensations of his
scholars, was by much too small. This has been in part remedied: the
teachers have now a salary of 15/. per annum, and a portion of land,
varying from three to more acres, according to the quality of the land,
a small house to reside in, and a school-room built and kept in repair
by the society. These teachers are Presbyterians, and under the
superintendance of the general assembly.
The church establishment of Scotland is favourable to its school
establishments the constant residence of the clergy upon their benefices
places the conduct of the schoolmaster and the application of his
scholars under the fostering protection of his superintendence, and the
teacher himself is often appointed to a vacant benefice.
Instruction in these schools is deeply tinged with religion. The
Catechism of the Assembly, the Proverbs of Solomon, and the New and Old
Testament, either in English or in Gaelic, impart to the mind of" the
rustic student a knowledge of the sacred writings, conformably to the
doctrines of Calvin. To preserve their flock, and not to enlarge it by
proselytism, seems to have been the sound wisdom of the Scottish
legislators. I am assured that proselytism is never attempted. In the
country, the English language, writing and arithmetic, are taught at the
rate of six shillings, and Latin at the rate of ten or twelve shillings
a year. In the towns the prices are higher, but in some places lower
than the sums mentioned.
The Highland schools are of more recent institution, and arise from the
beneficial effects already experienced from the parish schools. By the
4th George I. chap. 6, it is enacted, “That of the moneys arising from
the sale of the Scottish estates, forfeited in the rebellion of 1715,
2000/. sterling shall be converted into a capital stock, the interest of
which shall be laid out in erecting and maintaining schools in the
Highlands.”
The charity schools established by the Society for propagating Christian
Knowledge are, in the next degree, entitled to our consideration. This
association derived its origin from the public spirit of a few private
gentlemen in Edinburgh, who, in the beginning of the last century,
formed themselves into “A Society for the Reformation of Manners,”
principally in the Highlands and Hebrides, on account of their remote
situation, their total want of schools, the small number of Protestant
clergy in the country, the immense extent of parishes, the little
intercourse between them and their ministry (who are separated from them
by vast mountainous tracts, mountains, arms of the sea, and rivers often
impassable), by their language (a dialect of the ancient Celtic,
unintelligible to the inhabitants of the Low countries of Scotland), the
prevalence of popery in many districts, and the influence of clanship.
All these circumstances induced them to erect and endow schools,
provided with well qualified teachers, in as many districts of the
Highlands as possible, for the instruction of youth in the first
principles of religion and literature. Their funds were at first small,
but private contributions soon swelled the scanty stream into a noble
current; and the subscribers were erected into a body corporate by Queen
Ann, in 1709 under the title they now bear; some time afterwards they
obtained from the crown an enlargement of their powers, that they might
add to their primary objects the cultivation of the most necessary
branches of industry ; in consequence of which the women in the remote
Highlands, who used to be employed, as is frequently the case in
uncivilized countries, in the masculine labours of the field, were
engaged in sewing, spinning, knitting stockings, and other occupations
more appropriate to the sex.
By liberal contributions, and by the great disinterestedness and
discretion of all parties concerned, the funds of this society are in a
flourishing condition, though still unequal to the objects of its
application, which are continually increasing ; the promoters of it have
however the happiness of reflecting that they afford every year the
elementary branches of education to nearly 16,000 children. The schools
of the society are annually visited by two ministers of every presbytery
within whose bounds they are stationed: and at these visitations a
report is written and transmitted to the society of the number of the
scholars, the branches they are taught, and of their proficiency ; also
of the character and conduct of the teacher, and of the nature of the
accommodations furnished to him, in compliance with the rules of the
society: and until such report is received at the office of the society,
the salary of the teacker is not paid. This society has caused to be
translated the Scriptures both of the Old and New Testament, as well as
a variety of pious and useful treatises, into the Gaelic language, and
by means of their schoolmasters have circulated them through the
Highlands and islands.
The Highlanders, it is well known, are very proud of literary
distinction; and their ambition to teach others, after they have been
taught themselves, is very great. Hence the society have upon their
lists more candidates than they can appoint. The expenses of this noble
institution are conducted with the greatest economy and integrity.
Besides these established schools, the lojyer classes of people xn
Scotland, where the parishes are large, often combine together, and form
private schools of their own. So convinced are the poor people of
Scotland of the advantages of education, that they will submit to almost
any privation to procure it for their children, in doing which they have
to encounter the expense of clothing and feeding them. At the charity
schools no fees are paid. The benefits derived from these schools to the
rural Muse of Scotland are too well known to be enumerated. In
opposition to Dr. Johnson’s remark, that the schools are deserted in the
winter on account of the scarcity of food, it is a well-known fact that
the schools are much more frequented in that season than in summer, when
the children of those who are fit for, and are required in domestic
services are most wanted. The winter, moreover, is not penurious of food
in the Hebrides, as the natives are too careful not to provide for that
gloomy season of the year.
I shall close my account of these great intellectual sources with the
following singular remark made upon them by a Scotchman :—A lady of
rank, who had a Highlander in her service, whom she employed as her
hair-dresser, one morning as he was, adjusting her head, asked him how
many traditionary poems concerning Fingal still remained amongst his
countrymen ; to which he replied, « When any stranger entered a Highland
cottage, the first question always was from the family to the guest,
"Know you any thing of Fingal, or Ossian, or Oscar?” If he did, he was
called upon to recite what he knew; if he did pot,, they recited it to
him; and upon the lady asking how they could treasure up in their
memories so many poems, he said, "Oh, madam before we had so many
schools, we had long memories.”
As another mode of diffusing knowledge in the Highlands, I must not omit
to mention, that, a short time before I arrived at Inverness, a weekly
newspaper had been established, with every prospect of success, by a
very respectable bookseller, Mr. John Young, which considering the
improvements that have been made in the Highlands in agriculture, in
external and internal commerce/ and the general condition of the people,
is like to be of considerable public advantage, as well as a source of
private amusement, by opening new communications of intelligence. It is
rather singular that this should have been the first public print in
these parts. |