The nation was now delivered from the incubus of the
French arms; and by a higher award than that of war, it was also
delivered at the same instant from the incubus of French councils. When
the negotiations for peace were on the point of commencing, the supreme
hand of Divine Providence interposed and removed the Queen-Regent by
death. She expired in the castle of Edinburgh on the 10th of June 1560,
after expressing her regret to several of the Protestant
lords "that she had acted so foolishly as to compel them to seek the
support of others than their own sovereign, and her sore repentance that
ever matters had come to that extremity." Her decease was a death-blow
to the influence of France in Scottish affairs; and the government of
the kingdom under the absent sovereign passed into the hands of the men
who, with the help of England, had just worked out the emancipation of
the nation from a foreign yoke.
By one of the articles of the treaty of peace, it had
been provided that Parliament should be convened on the first day of
August; and as the treaty had settled nothing on the question of
religion, but had left that whole matter to be determined by the voice
of the Three Estates, all men looked forward to the coming convention as
one of the most important that had ever been held since Scotland was a
nation. It was felt by all that the moment of decision had at length
arrived; the nation was free to utter all that was in its heart;
and it would now give effect to its convictions and wishes by acts of
legislation, which would determine the religious institutions of the
kingdom for ages to come. To have a seat and a vote in such an assembly
was a privilege to be envied; and no fewer than one hundred and five of
the lesser barons, who had long neglected to attend the meetings of
parliament as a burden and expense, prepared to assert their ancient
privilege of sitting and voting in the great council of the nation.
We are fortunately able to narrate the proceedings of
this memorable assembly in the very terms in which they were originally
chronicled by an intelligent spectator for the eye of Sir William Cecil.
The Secretary had an agent resident in Edinburgh at the time—Thomas
Randolph ; and the letters are still extant in which Randolph recorded
the scenes and transactions of the Parliament as they passed before him.
We have also at our command several letters to the same statesman from
the pen of William Maitland, of Lethington,
who was chosen
Speaker of the Parliament, or Harangue-maker, as that high functionary
was then called in Scotland1 The Lords began to assemble in Edinburgh on
the ist of August, but not in sufficient numbers to commence business.
The formal opening was therefore delayed till the eighth of the month,
and u hitherto," says Randolph, writing a few days before that date, "as
many as have been present of the Lords have convened and devised of
certain heads then to be proposed, as who shall be sent into France, who
into England, &c. The barons, who in times past have been of the
Parliament, had yesterday a convention among themselves in the church,
in very honest and quiet s&rt They thought it good to require to be
restored unto their ancient liberty to have voice in Parliament They
presented that day a bill unto the Lords to that effect It was answered
unto gently, and taken in good part It was reserved unto the lords of
the articles, when chosen, to resolve thereupon."
The solemn opening of
Parliament on the 8th is thus graphically described by Randolph in a
letter written on the following day:—" The Lords at ten of the clock
assembled themselves at the palace, where the Duke lyeth. From thence
they departed towards the Tolbooth, as they were in dignity (/. e. in
the order of their rank). Each one being set in his seat, the crown, the
mace, and the sword were laid in the Queen's seat. Silence being
commanded, the Laird of Lethington began his oration. He excused his
insufficiency to occupy that place. He made a brief discourse of things
past, and unto what necessity men were forced for the defence of their
country; what remedy and support it pleased God to
send them in the time of
their necessity, and how much they were bound heartily to acknowledge it
and to requite it He took away the persuasion that was in many men's
heads that lay back, who misdeemed other things to be intended than was
attempted. He advised all classes to lay all particulars apart, and to
bend themselves wholly to the true service of God and their country. He
willed them to remember what state it had been in of long time for lack
of good government and execution of justice. In the end he exhorted them
to mutual amity and heartlie friendship, and to live with one another as
members all of one body. He used the example of the fable where the
mouth denied to receive sustenance to nourish the rest of the body so
long that the whole perished. He prayed God long to maintain this amity
and peace with all princes, and especially betwixt the realms of England
and Scotland, in the love and fear of God. And so ended—"
The Clerk of the Register
immediately stood up, and asked them to which matter they would proceed.
It was thought good that the articles of the peace should be confirmed
with the common consent, for that it was thought necessary to send them
away with speed into France, and to receive the ratification of them as
soon as might be. The articles being read were immediately agreed unto;
a day was appointed to have certain of the nobles subscribe unto them,
and to put their seals; immediately to be sent away by a herald who
shall also bring the ratification of them again with him. The barons of
whom I have above written, required an answer to their request. Somewhat
was said unto the contrary. The barons alleged for them custom and
authority. It was in the end resolved that there should six of them be
chosen to join with the lords of the articles, and if that they, after
good advisement, should find it right and necessary for the
commonwealth, it should be ratified at this Parliament for a perpetual
law.
"The lords proceeded
immediately hereupon to the choosing of the lords of the articles. The
order is that the lords spiritual choose the temporal, and the temporal
the spiritual; the burgesses their own. This being done, the lords
departed and accompanied the Duke, all as far as the Bow, which is the
gate going out of the High-street, and many down unto the palace—the
town all in armour, the trumpets sounding, and all other kinds of music,
such as they have. Thus much I report unto your honour of that which I
did both hear and see. Other solemnities have not been used, saving in
times long past the lords have had Parliament robes, which are now with
them wholly out of use. The lords of the articles sit from henceforth in
Holyrood House, except at such times as upon any matter of importance
the whole lords assemble themselves again as they did this day in the
Parliament House."
The choice of the lords of the articles was a p6int
of vital importance, as to them was entrusted the initiation and first
drafting of all important measures; and the choice which was now made
gave great satisfaction to all the friends of the Reformation. "It were
too long," writes Randolph on the 10th, "to trouble your honour to
rehearse particularly the nature, disposition, and chiefly the
affections that are judged to reign in each of these men that are at
this time chosen lords of the articles. May it suffice your honour for
this time to know, that by the common opinion of men there was not a
more substantial or more sufficient number of all sorts of men chosen in
Scotland many years, nor in whom men had greater hope of good to ensue.
It is no small pleasure to many here that the two old bishops are none
of them." The prelates referred to were the Archbishop of St. Andrews
and the Bishop of Dunkeld. In fact, almost the whole of the bishops and
abbots made choice of, had recently declared themselves on the side of
Reform. The whole number of the lords of the articles was 36, including
10 lords spiritual, 10 nobles or great barons, 6 lesser barons, and 10
provosts of the chief towns of the kingdom.
Meanwhile Knox was "instant in season" in the pulpit
of St. Giles. Choosing as his subject of daily exposition the Book of
the Prophet Haggai; "his doctrine was proper for the
time, in application whereof he was so special and so vehement that
some, having greater respect to the world than to God's glory, feeling
themselves pricked, said in mockage,' We must now forget ourselves, and
bear the barrow to build the houses of God.' But albeit some mocked, yet
others were godly moved, who did assemble themselves together to consult
what things were to be proposed to that present Parliament" The result
of these consultations was a supplication " to the nobility and estates
of Parliament from the barons, gentlemen, burgesses, and others
professing the Lord Jesus Christ within the realm," which was ready to
be presented to the lords of the articles as soon as they convened.
This supplication earnestly "craved, in the bowels of
Jesus Christ," three principal things: 1. That such doctrine and
idolatry, as by God's word are condemned, may be abolished by act of
this present Parliament, and punishment appointed for the transgressors,
2. That the pure administration of the sacraments and discipline of the
Church of Christ should be restored; and 3. That the usurped authority
and jurisdiction of the Pope within the realm should be abolished.
Having been " read in audience of the whole assembly, divers men
were of divers judgments, for as some there were that uprightly favoured
the cause of God, so were there many that for worldly respects abhorred
a perfect Reformation. And yet were the barons and ministers called, and
commandment given to them to draw in plain and several heads the sum of
that doctrine which they would maintain, and would desire that present
Parliament to establish as wholesome, true, and only necessary to be
believed, and to be received within that realm."
Within four days thereafter, Knox and the other
Protestant ministers assembled in Edinburgh had drawn up the First
Confession of the Reformed Church of Scotland. "Before it was
published," writes Randolph,"or many words spoken of it, it was
presented unto certain of the Lords to see their judgment It was
committed unto the Laird of Lethington, and the Subprior (John
Wynram), to be examined. Though they could not reprove the doctrines,
yet did they mitigate the austerity of many words and sentences, which
sounded to proceed rather of some evil-conceived opinion than of any
sound judgment. The authors of the work had also put in this treatise a
title or chapter of the obedience or disobedience that subjects owe unto
their magistrates, that contained little less matter in few words than
hath been otherwise written more at large. The surveyors of the work
thought it to be an unfit matter to be entreated at this time, and so
gave their advice to leave it out" The Confession, thus retrenched to
some extent both in matter and form, was unanimously accepted by the
lords of the articles. Writing to Cecil on the 15th, Maitland announced
to him that " already there is past the confession of our faith, by ane
unanimous consent of the haill lords of articles, to be sent to the King
and Queen. The whole estate of the clergy is on our side, a few excepted
of them that be present, as the Archbishop of St Andrews, and the
Bishops of Dumblane and Dunkeld. The religion is like enough to find
many favourers of the whole of all estates. As yet, praised be God,
there is no appearance of any division, but all like enough to continue
in a good amity. We thought good before all things to pass the
confession."
During the short interval
that elapsed before the Confession was submitted to the whole
Parliament, much influence was used and pains taken to gain over the
Archbishop and the two bishops, of which Randolph supplies us with the
following curious account On the 16th he tells Cecil that—
"The Bishop of St
Andrews, upon motion that was made to him, was contented to talk with
the Sub-prior, the Rector, and two others. They have had much
communication without hope. He is stout and bold enough. He rideth and
goeth at large. He came to the Duke to supper, invited and conveyed by
Mr. Gavin Hamilton, of Kilwinning. He was as homely as welcome. The Duke
after supper talked long with him; he was better willing to hear him
than to believe anything he spake. They concluded in these words, that
for his conscience he was determined, in that mind that he was of at
that present to end his life. For his body, goods, and living, he was
content to yield all into his hands. What besides matters of conscience
he would command him, he was always ready to obey. So that the Duke
thinketh to bring him to subscribe the contract (i>. the English
Treaty). The Bishop of Dunkell remaineth as obstinate as ignorant. Being
moved to hear Mr. Knox, he gave answer that he would never hear an old
condemned heretic Mr. Knox hath been with him for it since that time. So
have also divers others that have preached. Sermons are daily, and great
audience. Though divers of the nobles present are not resolved in
religion, yet do they repair daily to the preachings, which giveth a
good hope to many that God will turn their hearts. The Bishop of
Dumblane is also now come; it is not to reason upon religion, but to do,
as I hear, whatsomever the Earl of Argyle will command him. Mr. Knox and
Mr. Willock were yesterday before the lords of the articles with the
bishops. St Andrews desired to have a copy of the confession of their
faith. It was not denied him to have it shortly, though it be doubted
that it be to send it into France before the lords do send, more than
that he hath any mind to examine the verity or reform his conscience, be
it never so reasonable."
On the 17th day of
August, the Confession was read in audience of the whole Parliament, and
by the estates thereof ratified and approved, "as wholesome and sound
doctrine grounded upon the infallible word of God." On the 18th Maitland
communicated the important news to Cecil in the following terms :—
"The confession of our
faith was passed by common consent, where unto no man gainsayed, all
being present. It is true that the Archbishop of St Andrews, the Bishops
of Dunkeld and Dumblane, and two of the temporal lords, did excuse
themselves if they were not ready to speak their judgment, for that they
were not sufficiently advised with the book. Thus far they did liberally
profess, that they would agree to all things which might stand with
God's word, and consent to abolish all abuses crept in in the Church not
agreeable with the Scriptures, and asked longer time to deliberate on
the book propounded, whereby they did in a manner confirm our doctrine,
whereas they, having liberty to speak what pleased them, durst not
impugn it, and uttered their own ignorance to their confusion. It was no
small wonder to see what victory the truth did obtain by so uniform
consent We are not like to have many enemies at home."
Randolph's account of the
transaction is much more minute and is deeply interesting. He writes
like a chronicler, while Maitland writes like a statesman. In a letter
dated the 19th of August, he says:—
"As touchyng such things
as are concluded here in Parliament, and fully resolved upon hitherto, I
never heard matters of so great importance neither sooner despatched nor
with better will agreed unto. The matters concluded and past by common
consent on Saturday in such solemn sort as the first day that they
assembled, are these :—First, That the Barons, according to an old Act
of Parliament, made in James the First's times, the year of God 1427,
shall have free voice in Parliament This act passed without any
contradiction, as well of the bishops papists as all other present. The
next was the ratyfication of the confession of their faith; in the which
the Bishop of St Andrews, in many words, said this in effect: that it
was a matter that he had not been accustomed with ; he had had no
sufficient time to examine it or to confer with his friends ; howbeit,
as he would not utterly condemn it, so was he loth to give his consent
thereunto. To that effect also spake the Bishops of Dunkell and Dumblane.
Of the temporal lords, the Earl of Cassilis and the Earl of Caithness
said nay. The rest of the lords, with common consent, and as glad a will
as ever I heard men speak, allowed the same. Divers, with protestation
of their conscience and faith, desyred rather presently to end their
lives, than ever to think contrary unto that that they allowed then.
Many also offered to shed their blude in defense of the same. The old
Lord of Lindsay, as grave and goodly a man as ever I saw, said, 'I have
lived many years; I am the eldest in this company, of my sort; now that
it hath pleased God to let me see this day, when so many nobles and
others have allowed so worthy a work, I will say with Simeon, Nunc
dimittis.' The old Lord of Lundie confessed how long he had lived in
blindness, repented his former life, and embraced the same as his true
belief. My Lord James, after some other purpose, said that he must the
sooner believe it to be true, for that some others in the company did
not allow the same. 'Ye know that God's trothe would never be without
his adversaries.' The Lord Marschall said, that though he was otherwise
assured it was true, yet might he be the bolder to pronounce it, for
that he saw there present the pillars of the Pope's church, and not one
of them that would speak against it Many others to like effect, as the
Lord of Erskine, Lord of Newbottle, the Sub-prior of St Andrews,
concluding, all in one, that that was the faith wherein they ought to
live and die."
Never was confession of
faith accepted by a parliament or political assembly with so much
unanimity or so much emotion. In truth, the estates of the kingdom, in
this solemn act, merged their civil and political, in their religious
and ecclesiastical character. It was more like the act of a national
synod than a parliament. The Confession ran in the name of the Estates,
and was conceived much more in the spirit and tone of a solemn testimony
put forth to the world by a nation of earnest Christians—a testimony
which they were ready to seal with their blood—than in the cold,
scientific manner of a theological document Its language is earnest and
glowing. It is the warm utterance of a people's heart. "The Estates of
Scotland, with the inhabitants of the samyn, professing Christ Jesus,
his Holy Evangell," address themselves in it, "to their natural
countrymen, and to all other realms and nations professing the same Lord
Jesus with them ;n and it is in such words as the following that they
begin what reads rather like a declaration of the martyrs than a compend
of divinity. " Long have we thirsted, dear brethren, to have notified
unto the world the sum of that doctrine which we profess, and for the
which we have sustained infamy and danger..... For God we take to record
in our consciences that from our hearts we abhor all sorts of heresy,
and all teachers of erroneous doctrine, and that with all humility we
embrace the purity of Christ's Evangel, which is the only food of our
souls, and therefore so precious to us, that we are determined to suffer
the extremity of worldly danger, rather than that we will suffer
ourselves to be defrauded of the same. For hereof we are most certainly
persuaded, that whoever denies Christ Jesus, or is ashamed of him in
presence of men, shall be denied before the Father, and before his holy
angels. And, therefore, by the assistance of the mighty spirit of the
same our Lord Jesus, we firmly purpose to abide to the end, in the
confession of this our faith."
Before another week was
over, the lords of the articles had agreed to introduce to Parliament
other three Acts of great importance, which formed the natural sequel to
the national adoption of a Protestant confession. These were an "Act
against the Mass," an "Act for abolishing the Jurisdiction of the Pope,"
and an "Act, repealing all the penal statutes against heresy, under
which the nation had so long suffered." All these acts were passed with
unanimity by the Estates, on the 24th of August, of which meeting we
have the following account by Randolph.
Aug. 27. The Lords of the
Parliament assembled in the Tolbooth in like sort as the first of their
meeting confirmed there, by common consent, divers Acts agreed upon by
the Lords of the Articles, whereof the first was the confirmation of the
treaty at Berwick, which by the Lord of Liddington was notably commended
unto the lords, with ample declaration of the necessity of the time, the
occasion thereof, and the good will and favour of the Queen's Majesty,
to their relief in time of their extreme necessity and almost utter ruin
of the whole country. It passed with the common consent of all men;
divers also so much commended the same, that they said that they would
be content to seal it with their blood. Some exhorted all men constantly
to remain in that opinion, and never to swerve from the same. Others
praised the first motioners, and prayed for the life and welfare of her
Majesty, that was the performer. This ended, the lord James protested in
his own name and other of the contractors, that they might have an
instrument that their Act was allowed to be good, lawful, and not
prejudicial unto the crown of Scotland, and confirmed by common consent
of Parliament They have deposed the pope, and abrogated his authority
without contradiction. Many penal statutes against heretics are taken
away. The mass is utterly abolished, and pains appointed both to the
sayers and hearers. The first, confiscation of their goods, the next,
banishment, third, loss of their lives. The three bishops, St. Andrews,
Dumblane, and Dunkell, being called to pursue their bill of complaint of
the misusing ot them, and contempt of their authority, given to the
lords of the Articles, compeared not, whereupon a decree was made for
the stay of their livings. The Parliament is prorogued."
On the same day, the
27th, Maitland wrote to Cecil briefly, thus:—"Although our Parliament is
not ended, it is for the present, upon good respects, dissolved, and
many of our principal matters passed with a greater and more uniform
agreement of the most part than was looked for. There is, in a manner,
no controversy on religion, and much less anent maintenance of amity
with England, which all most earnestly wish may endure for ever, and
that the means of continuance may be embraced. The treaty of Berwick is
by Act of Parliament confirmed, which I doubt not shall highly irritate
the French."
Thus ended this memorable
meeting of the Parliament of Scotland—the greatest in its acts, and the
most weighty in its consequences, that ever assembled in the whole
course of Scottish History. It marked the close of the mediaeval history
of the kingdom, and commenced, with a series of great transactions, the
nation's modern life and development It was the era both of a grand
catastrophe, and of a grand new creation. Old things passed away, and
all things became new. A nation was born in a day to newness of life."
In one respect alone did the ideas of that great
social revolution and renovation fall behind the ideas of our own age.
The Parliament of 1560 enacted penal laws against the Romish worship, in
the room of those which had previously been enacted against the worship
of the Protestants. They imitated the intolerant legislation under which
they had themselves so long groaned. They denied to others that "
freedom and liberty of conscience" which they had at length wrought out
for themselves. It was undoubtedly an inconsistency on the score of
principle; but practically considered, it was a necessity of the times.
To us it appears a plain contradiction to the fundamental Protestant
principle of the duty and right of private judgment in matters of
religion; but to the Protestants of the sixteenth century, such
legislation seemed indispensable as a policy of self-defence. The
Papists, though beaten on many fields, were not yet conquered; they had
still immense powers in Europe; and they burned with impatience to
revenge their defeats, and to recover the ground which they had lost.
The war of churches continued, and a time of war suggests different
maxims of policy and government, from a time of peace. At such a time
men are less apt to consider how much they can give to an enemy, than
how much they can take away. We are prone to plume ourselves upon our
more enlightened principles of religious legislation, as though we had
attained to them purely by a superior degree of philosophic discernment
and political wisdom. But the altered conditions of the world and of the
Nations of the churches to each other have doubtless had much to do in
evolving these principles and elevating them to social power. After all,
if the Protestants of the nineteenth century are more tolerant than
those of the sixteenth, this is very much owing to the difference of the
times in other respects. The decline of ecclesiastical power in the
affairs of the world has delivered all Churches from the fear of
persecution at the hands of one another; and when intolerant laws are no
longer of any use for purposes either of offence or defence, there is no
great mental superiority evinced in allowing them to be expunged as a
dead letter from the statute books of nations.