By William Anderson Smith, Ledaig, Argyllshire.
[Premium—The Medium Gold Medal.]
In face of the Edinburgh Fisheries Exhibition,
originated by the Highland and Agricultural Society, and so successfully
conducted under its auspices, it would be out of place to devote much
space to the question of the fisheries ; but, as the subject is engaging
the particular attention of a Special Committee of that Society, I desire
to place before the public the necessities of the Highlands in this
connection, and the various directions in which enterprise might be
stimulated and encouraged.
It so happens that it has been necessary hitherto to
bring extraneous aid both in skill and money to develop all marine
industries along the Highland coast-line, as the only important centres of
such industries have been created from without, the natives, with some few
but important exceptions, neither showing skill as boatmen and fishermen,
nor love of seafaring. Yet the enormous extent of coast-line, the many
safe anchorages and harbours, the mildness of the western sea, and the
facilities in railway and steamboat communication fast being multiplied,
ought to direct especial attention to the undeveloped resources in these
waters, that might well relieve many over-populated districts from the
pressure that is upon them.
The poverty of the more isolated districts, preventing
the men obtaining the needful boats and gear, is gradually lessening
through a wider diffusion of wealth; and what is greatly required is a
wider diffusion of knowledge and skill, to enable the scattered population
to make use of the resources often at their door.
Of recent years much progress has been made in the
western herring fishery, various new stations having been established of
an important character; while the whole west coast has been tapped by
steamers in the herring season to an extent never hitherto attempted. This
has done more, however, to bring boats from the east than to develop the
west coast fishery as a local industry, and not until the coast population
are stimulated to attempt the capture of the ordinary white fish off the
shore, and so gradually accustomed to seafaring and the careful handling
of craft, will they acquire skill sufficient to enable them successfully
to follow the bolder branches of the profession well out to the deeper
banks.
The use of the long line or bulter, as employed in the
cod and ling fishery, is mostly confined to special centres where this
fishery is conducted, but has not extended to the outlying districts where
fish are to be had in at least sufficient quantity to supply the locality,
while occasionally considerable supplies could be forwarded to the more
populous districts. The consequence of this want of gear and skill is that
we are exceedingly ignorant as to the marine resources of the west,
neither knowing properly what species of fish are common, nor where they
are obtainable; while, wherever the herring fishery is in full swing, all
other fish are neglected, as they show but a poor return for the labour
expended compared with this prolific fish.
As examples of what fisheries are worthy of attention,
I may instance mullet, which are plentiful in certain localities, but
through ignorance of the proper mode of capture, and perhaps
want of the proper appliances, I never see one for sale,
and •rarely hear of a capture.
I have seen the sand smelt (Atherina) in
quantities, but the people were equally ignorant of their character, and
in want of the required nets to enclose them.
The conger eel, which is a good and wholesome, and at
any rate a marketable fish, is only sought as bait for the cod and ling
boats, while they might form an important winter fishery if regularly sent
to the southern markets.
Whiting are more especially plentiful in some seasons
in our sea-lochs, where these are largely supplied with fresh water; but
their capture is only intermittent, partial, and for local consumpt. The
people have not learned that they are valuable as a marketable commodity,
and that it is worth expending care and assiduity in their capture. But
perhaps the most remarkable instance of disregard of a valuable industry
is that of the fresh-water eel, which can only be termed "marine" from its
frequenting the sea to spawn. Neither eating what is to them an unclean
and disgusting object, nor capturing it for sale, it is allowed to swarm
on all our coasts, occasionally to the serious injury of the fry of the
Salmonidae; and its neglect represents a loss to the country which may
well be calculated at a very large sum, seeing that the eel fishery of
Ireland is scarcely, if at all, inferior in value to her salmon fishery.
It is hardly conceivable, but throughout the Highlands you will scarcely
ever see an eel trap, nor, indeed, can they be purchased in the west, to
our knowledge; the only specimen exhibited in Edinburgh being wholly
unsuited for the purpose designed. What is wanted is the distribution of a
few properly made osier traps, so that the scattered population may
understand their construction, and the value of the creature they are
designed to capture, in the market. This ignorance of apparatus is so
widespread that we look to the new Committee of the Society to use their
influence in obtaining proper exhibits of the best appliances for fish
capture, to be loaned throughout the Highlands to the different coast
districts as a means of education, to supplement the annual shows of the
Society, now thrown open so liberally to all connected with the fisheries.
There is scarcely a stream with a coast exit but is
well filled with an eel population, and as the elder members freely prey
upon their weaker brethren, the annual removal of a large proportion of
the more marketable eels would only improve the streams as eel preserves.
These same streams can for the most part readily be
made available for sea trout, by merely breeding and turning loose a
moderate number annually, which will return thither in the breeding
season; and even when the stream is so small as to offer scarcely any
facility for the passage of sea-trout, a very little expenditure would
form a pool or pools a short way from the mouth of the stream, where good
sport and an important aggregate food-supply could be obtained. Large fish
will make strenuous endeavours to pass up the very smallest water-courses,
or wait patiently for a spate to enable them to do so; while it is rare
that they would require to wait long in the rainy west.
The coasts of the Western Highlands and Islands are
well supplied with sandy and muddy stretches of foreshore, where the
various flat fish abound; and yet, partly through ignorance of their
value, partly through dislike of all flat fish, the inhabitants rarely
capture any of them, and never send them to market.
I will not at present touch upon the advantage of
breeding artificially the finer qualities of these fish, so as to
supersede the plaice on these feeding grounds ; although this is quite a
feasible, and in our opinion not a difficult operation. But we merely call
attention to these sources of supply as at least of local value. The Broad
Bay flounder of Stornoway, and celebrated flounder of Iona, are noted
instances of superior fish.
A fresh hake is a fish that is looked upon by many as
an especially delightful dish, and yet this fish is never seen in the
market, although comparatively plentiful on many parts of our western
coast.
I am not aware that the tusk or torsk is ever captured
south of Ardnamurchan, but it is one of the finest of the Gardidae when
fresh, in our opinion; and I am persuaded that if the fishermen of the
north were once to have it properly introduced into the market, this firm,
nourishing, and agreeable fish would soon become a public favourite. Along
the Hebridean coast-line the turbot was usually classed among "flounders"
in our experience, and we have frequently purchased fish at 1s. each that
would have been worth 30s. in the London market. A very great number of
these fishes are cut up for bait in the cod and ling fishery, and a little
arrangement might readily bring them before a more appreciative set of
customers. The same may be said of the halibut, a fish only of recent
introduction to our markets in the west of Scotland, and one that ought to
be procurable in far greater abundance than at present, as it is by no
means an uncommon fish on the western banks. Foremost among fishes that
are wholly neglected along the western seaboard, I would place the skate,
especially the thornback skate, which is rarely captured except when it
ought to be let alone, namely, when it comes into shoal water to deposit
its eggs. These fish are very numerous among the muddy lochs of the
Highlands, and living for the most part upon Crustacea, and frequenting
comparatively shallow water, they ought to be readily captured, and
constitute an industry of some value. They are readily kept alive, and
easily fed upon crabs, and could thus be kept until wanted, when they
might be crimped and promptly despatched to the nearest market. By
protecting them in May and June, when they come shoreward to lay their
eggs, the stock could easily be kept up, and their capture of a moderate
size can be readily effected with small lines baited with hermit crabs or
whilks.
There is yet another class of fishes quite ignored
among us. We refer to the species of sandlaunce (Ammodytes), those
delicious fish, which in many quarters are so highly prized, and are only
inferior in delicacy to the smelt. They are very numerous in our extensive
western sands, and ought to be assiduously sought after, either for local
consumption, or, where practicable, for prompt despatch to a ready market.
The whole West Highlands of Scotland being comparatively virgin ground,
without the danger of interfering with vested interests of an irremovable
character, such as meet the fish-culturist on the English rivers and
coasts, no better time than the present could present itself for the wise
and judicious supervision of the coast in connection with its marine
industries.
The great success of lobster ponds made out of any
suitable small arm of the sea, into which lobsters may be placed in the
summer time, and kept until the winter season, ought to stimulate efforts
to improve upon this by both breeding and feeding them in such "lobsteries."
The West Highlands lend themselves admirably to efforts in this direction,
and I cannot understand how it has never paid any one to despatch the fine
crabs of the north and west to the southern markets. As a rule,
consignments of these have never been successful, and I am strongly
inclined to question whether such consignments have had fair play in the
open market. The supply is unquestionable, and the quality superior,
without being overgrown, and I could wish that a bona fide
experiment were made on a proper scale with this commodity.
The idea of enclosed rocky ponds might be greatly
extended in the west and north, where such baylets frequently open direct
from the outer ocean. At Arcachon there are ponds into which sea fish
enter freely as fry, and where they are then secured by closing the
entrances except to the inflow and outflow of water. The fish are kept
there until they attain a marketable size. This principle could easily be
carried out in many districts at small cost, and the coast, indeed, ought
to be lined with similar feeding-places, whence the fish could be taken
during severe weather, and despatched to good markets.
It is scarcely credible the quantity of cockles that
can be obtained from certain portions of our coast, of a quality so
superior as to be little inferior to oysters. And yet we never heard of
any being despatched to market from the Highlands, although they form such
an extensive industry on the English coast, where this shell-fish is
distinctly inferior in flavour to the northern mollusc. There is surely
room here for encouraging a traffic among our poor island populations.
The periwinkle (Littorea littorina), again, is
exported in large quantities under the name of "whilk," and yet the real
whilk is never gathered, either for local consumption or export; whereas
there is not only a good demand for these mollusca as food in the cities,
but a still better demand for them as bait in the line fisheries. We
should prefer to see our own line fisheries so developed as to demand all
that the localities could supply, but in the absence of this a distinct
industry could be created out of these carnivorous shell-fish themselves;
and this might lead more readily to the further development of the capture
of those various fishes that these mollusca are employed to allure. From
the quantity of whilk spawn thrown, its accessibility, and the readiness
with which it lends itself to culture, we are strongly of opinion that an
opening for an industry may be found in their artificial propagation in
certain localities. The so-called "whilk," or periwinkle, trade is already
a large one in the Highlands, and we believe would be locally improved by
the more regular cutting of the sea-ware. This is commonly allocated to
particular farmers ex adverso the coast, and we consider that so
long as they claim such allocation they should be obliged to perform their
part of the contract, and cut the whole portion allocated every third
year. This would supply the winkles with fresher pasture, and enable the
same coast-line to carry a larger stock. The great stretches of uncut ware
in many districts represent a double loss to the locality in manure and
periwinkles. I will not enlarge upon the vast importance of the mussel
harvest, that only requires gathering in many places, and would amply
repay attention in others.
Those splendid shell-fish, the myae, tapes, and solens,
are all worthy of note, and ought at least to prove an aid to the local
populations, many of whom will not at present condescend to touch them. Is
there no way of teaching their practical value, and stimulating the coast
population to test their nourishing and palatable qualities ? Many of
these very shell-fish that are despised at our own doors are imported
tinned from the American seaboard! How much more agreeable and nourishing
they are fresh, and how readily they will bear carriage to market, ought
surely to be more widely known.
Over a great portion of the west coast, at a few
fathoms depth, a good supply of scallops, or Pectens is procurable,
and these are among the most delicate shell-fish that our waters can
supply, more especially the species P. opercularis. On the east
coast they are mostly dredged for bait, but if it were generally known how
superior they were when fresh from the water, they would be assiduously
sought after as a table delicacy. Unfortunately they cannot retain a
supply of water, and consequently will not carry far or keep ; but they
could be placed in ponds when captured, and sent off by train when
desired.
Apart from the food supply, there are other industries
that would well repay encouragement and industrious pursuit.
Although carrageen, or Irish moss, is not so much in
fashion as it once was, or as it deserves to be, for puddings, it is still
of value commercially, and would yield a fair return if despatched to
cotton manufacturing districts for the making of size. This fine purple
alga grows freely along our coasts, and can be gathered in quantity at
very little cost of labour.
Another article that could readily be garnered in large
quantities, and would always find a ready market, is Zostera marina
or sea-wrack. This grass grows just beyond ordinary low water, but can
easily be cultivated along muddy coasts, where it not only improves the
ground for the culture of oysters, but renders it firm and more
traversible. Considering the excitement over it as a possible source of
fibre during the cotton famine, we are surprised that attention has so
soon been removed from its unquestionable claims. As stuffing for
cushions, and for upholstery generally, it is even now largely used; the
bulk, we believe, coming from Holland.
The utilisation of other marine products ought also to
attract enterprise. The skin of the rough hound (Squale rousette)
is no longer in great demand for shagreen, yet we see no reason why it
should not be largely used in other manufactures in which ingenuity and
skill are employed. I see no reason why it should not form a basis for
such manufacture as much as the skin of the alligator, which of late years
has fetched such large prices and come so much into favour; not so much
from its intrinsic value, as from the taste and elegance of the articles
manufactured from it.
The same may be said for shell ornaments. Our shells
are quite fit to compete in this direction with those of most other
countries, but what is wanted is good taste and artistic knowledge. We
must confess, that at present our shell ornaments are not such as to
induce purchasers of taste to invest.
When we think of our enormous Highland coast-line, and
the hundreds of thousands of acres of utilisable foreshores, we cannot but
conclude that there is great remissness somewhere, when our marine
industries of all kinds are so backward in the Highlands. The population
may not be naturally a seafaring race, but they are capable of being
stimulated to any class of industry when once they are shown the way; and
I have endeavoured to trace out a few directions in which they may be
successful in utilising—at small cost to start with—some of the really
vast resources of our Highland lochs and outer waters.
I have already had occasion to refer to the necessity
for a clearer understanding as to the foreshore ownership, so that the
public interested might more readily know how to obtain legal sanction for
attempts at foreshore cultivation of whatever kind. The prevailing
uncertainty is a great stumbling-block to any such efforts. When it is not
otherwise distinctly acknowledged, the proposed marine cultivator,
however, may conclude that the ordinary Highland proprietor claims the
control of the shores ex adverso his estate, and acts accordingly.
A difficulty is seldom raised, except on important occasions; but the
successful creation of a new industry is just such an occasion as would
raise questions that ought previously to have been settled!
Would it be too much to ask those Highland proprietors
connected with the Highland Society, who have a right to their ex
adverso foreshores, and are willing to encourage all bona fide
efforts at marine cultivation, to register their names and coastline in
the Transactions of the Society, as the first important step
towards a proper understanding?