"HEUBEUX le peuple dont l’histoire
ennuie," say the French, and if this be a
just criterion of national prosperity, it must be confessed that the
Highlanders of Scotland have no mean claim to be considered as one of the
happiest people in Europe. Just as this remark may be with regard to
Highland history, it would not be easy to assign a reason for it, still
less to account for the general neglect which the history of that people
has experienced, in an age when the early annals of almost every nation
have been examined, and their true origin and history determined, with a
talent and success to which no other period can show a parallel.
The cause of this somewhat
remarkable fact may, perhaps, be traced to the influence of that
extraordinary prejudice against the Celtic race in general, and against
the Scottish and Irish branches of that race in particular, which
certainly biased the better judgment of our best historians, who appear to
have regarded the Highlands with somewhat of the spirit of those who said
of old, "Can any good thing come out of Nazareth." But it is mainly to be
attributed to the neglect, by the indiscreet supporters of Highland
fables, of that strictly critical accuracy, in point of evidence and of
reasoning, so indispensable to the value of historical research the want
of which infallibly leads to the loose style of argument and vague
assumption so remarkably characteristic of that class of writers, and
tends unfortunately to draw down upon the subject itself no small share of
that ridicule to which the authors were more justly liable. The prevailing
error which appears to me to have misled almost all who have as yet
written upon the subject, has been the gratuitous assumption, not only by
those whose writings are directed against the claims of the Highlanders,
but also by their numerous defenders, that the present Highlanders are the
descendants of the ancient Scotti, who, in company with the Picti, so
often ravaged the Roman provinces in Britain. Nor have either party deemed
it necessary to bring either argument or authority in support of their
assumption. The Scots, as will be shewn in the sequel, were unquestionably
a colony issuing from Ireland in the sixth century; and thus, while the
one party triumphantly asserts the Irish origin of the Highlanders, their
defenders have hitherto directed their efforts to the fruitless attempt of
proving that the Scots were the original inhabitants of the country.
The attention of the Author was
directed to this subject by an advertisement of, the Highland Society of
London, making offer of a premium for the best History of the Highland
Clans; his Essay proved the successful one, and the Highland Society
deemed his Work worthy of the attention of the public, and requested that
it might be published. Since that period the Author has been enabled to
make many important additions to the original Essay, and has considerably
altered its plan and arrangement. In collecting the materials of the
present Work, the Author has to acknowledge the very liberal assistance
which he has received from many of his literary friends in Scotland and he
feels that it would be improper to allow this opportunity to escape
without acknowledging the very great obligations which he has been laid
under by Donald Gregory, Esq., Secretary to the Society of Antiquaries of
Scotland, for the valuable and important communications which he has at
all times so liberally made to the Author; and also by Mr. T. G. Repp, for
the able assistance which he has rendered to the Author in the earlier
part of his enquiry.
In presenting this Work to the
public it will be necessary to say a few words regarding the system of
history developed in it. A glance at the Table of Contents will shew that
that system is entirely new that it is diametrically opposed to all the
generally received opinions on the subject, and that it is in itself of a
nature so startling, as to require a very rigid and attentive examination
before it can be received. The Author had, from a very early period, been
convinced that the present system was erroneous, and that there was in it
some fundamental error, which prevented the elucidation of the truth.
Accordingly, after a long and attentive examination of the early
authorities in Scottish history, together with a thorough investigation of
two new and most valuable sources— viz., the Icelandic Sagas in their
original language and the Irish Annals—-he came to the conclusion, that
that fundamental error was the supposed descent of the Highlanders from
the Dalriadic Scots, and that the Scottish conquest in the ninth century
did not include the Highlands. Proceeding upon this basis, the system of
history developed in the following pages naturally emerged; and in it will
be found the first attempt to trace the Highlanders, and to prove their
descent, step by step, from the Caledonians—an attempt which the
incontrovertible Irish origin of the Dalriadic Scots has hitherto rendered
altogether unsuccessful. The Author is aware that to many this system may
appear wild and visionary, but he feels confident that a perusal of the
chain of reasoning contained in the first few chapters, will be sufficient
to satisfy any unprejudiced enquirer that the true origin of the
Highlanders is therein ascertained, and that their descent from the
Caledonians rests upon historic authority of no ordinary strength. The
same remarks which apply generally to the origin of the Highlanders, are
true also with regard to the Highland clans: the descent of each of these
has been traced and proved from the most authentic documents, while the
absurdity of the Irish origins of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries,
as well as the Scandinavian dreams of later historians, have been shewn.
With these remarks, the Author
leaves his Work to the judgment of the public, and he may conclude with
the words of a celebrated foreign historian, "There can be no greater
enjoyment to the inquisitive mind than to find light where he has hitherto
found nothing but darkness. More than once I have experienced this
agreeable sensation in the progress of the present investigation, and I
may venture with the more confidence to deliver this Work from my hands to
the reader, because happily I can safely assert, that much which formerly
appeared to him only in doubtful and obscure gloom, will now he seen in
the full and clear light of day."