The Scottish Second Eleven Association was formed by
another Queen's Park member, Mr. John K. M'Dowall, afterwards secretary of
the Scottish Football Association. Mr. M'Dowall seems to have been a born
secretary, as from his earliest youth he had a penchant for secretarial
work, and wherever his superabundant energies could find employment he was
at the helm, the moving spirit, the organiser, the statistician, and the
head and front of everything he took in hand. He is a creature of method, a
master of facts, which he arrays so that they are available at a moment's
notice. These are not selfishly stored, but are generously placed at the
disposal of friends in search of information, who are thus saved months of
weary and often abortive research, no matter how painstaking the student of
history, and especially of football history, may be. An author himself, he
has written an abridged "History of Glasgow"—a fund of information now
difficult to obtain—a writer of several monologues on Burns, the national
poet, and other Scottish poets, and Napoleon; an antiquarian, bibliophile,
philatelist, and numismatist, he has a sympathy with authors, and helps them
on their way to the goal they aim at. He was a member of the Glasgow School
Board, and is a Justice of the Peace for the County of the City of Glasgow.
This story of the Queen's Park could not have developed as it has without
his kindly support and interest. It may not be generally known that Mr.
M'Dowall is a very old-member of the Queen's Park, which he joined as a
youth in 1879. Here his secretarial instinct at once found a ready field.
First associated with the Hampden Eleven, of which he was captain and match
secretary, he subsequently officiated as captain of the Second Queen's Park.
As he apparently wished to travel faster than the committee desired while
handling the Second Eleven, he got into some amusing scrapes, which were no
doubt troublesome enough for him at the time. He somehow always managed to
escape serious consequences, and generally emerged from his difficulties
with flying colours. His was the fate of all reformers. In the first place,
at the half-yearly general meeting in 1881, he suggested that a stove should
be placed in the pavilion, as many comforts would be gained thereby. The
committee, after a general conversation, were unanimous in the opinion that
the stove was not required. This was cold comfort. However, Mr. M'Dowall got
his stove a few months later. Mr. M'Dowall's first little difficulty arose
through taking the Hampden Eleven to Campsie, when they should have played
Second Alexandra Athletic. His explanation of the incident was considered
equivocal and unsatisfactory. "The meeting had to be content" with the
excuse that Mr. M'Dowall had left a message with the office boy of the A.A.C.
secretary, and the boy delivered the message wrongly. No one knows what the
message was. Mr. M'Dowall at this period, February, 1882, decided to
establish the Scottish Second Eleven Association, and entered the Second
Queen's Park—it was not called the Strollers until 7th July, 1885—without
consulting the committee, and even had the temerity to place the team in the
draw for the "Second Eleven Challenge Cup,'' for which delinquency he was
hauled before the magnates of the club. The secretary is terribly sarcastic
in his minutes. He says: "Mr. M'Dowall stated that he was the originator and
organiser of this brilliant scheme. He it was who summoned representatives
from the various Second Eleven teams in Scotland, but—strange to say —there
was no representative from the Queen's Park. He scorned the imputation that
in his own person was embodied the 'Second Queen's Park'—such an idea was
simply absurd. His own reputation was a sufficient guarantee that the scheme
was one worthy of the attention of clubs like Dumbarton, Vale, etc., and he
had attended the meeting in a private capacity. True, he was appointed
secretary, but why he could not say.. On being asked to explain the
appearance of the Second Queen's Park, he said he thought if the second
teams of the other great clubs entered, that the Second Queen's Park would
also enter, and that it would be no harm in
drawing them with the rest," Yet it was Mr. Geake's suggestion in his report
to the annual general meeting that started the idea. Mr. Geake criticised
this conduct. Some members present got first intimation on the matter from
reading the drawings in the press. "Mr. M'Dowall was
gently reprimanded by the chairman, and withdrew."
Afterwards Mr. Geake stated Mr. M'Dowall had asked and obtained from the
match committee, at their meeting the previous night, permission to enter
the Second Queen's Park, subject to the assent of the committee.
Nevertheless, the committee refused to allow the team to compete for the
cup. On a memorial from nine members of the Second Eleven, who were eager
for the fray, the question was reopened at a special meeting of the club,
14th February, 1882. Some members: were inclined to modify their views,
urging that the second team as a whole should not be made to suffer for the
injudicious and precipitate haste of one of its members. After motions and
counter-motions, that of Mr. A. Rowan, seconded by Mr. C. Campbell—always
sympathetic with the indiscretions of youth—was carried, "That the Second
Eleven be allowed to compete for the cup, but that the committee express
their disapproval of the way in which it was entered." A letter sent to Mr.
M'Dowall intimating this decision " was not acknowledged or taken any notice
of in any way." Mr. M'Dowall had his association now complete, and proceeded
to business. The birth of the Scottish Second Eleven Association was on this
wise. The meeting at which the Scottish Second Eleven was formed was held in
11 Carlton Place in October, 1881—Mr. Walter Crichton (Alexandra Athletic)
in the chair. It was decided to found such an association, and the rules and
constitution of the Scottish Football Association, as far as suitable, were
adopted. Mr. John K. M'Dowall, who called the meeting, was appointed its
first secretary, which position he filled until he became secretary of the
Scottish Football Association in 1882. Mr. John Murphy (South-Western) then
took up the secretarial pen, which he wielded for about four years, when Mr.
M'Dowall was reappointed. He found the affairs of the Association in a far
from satisfactory position, and proceeded at once to reorganise the
association. He has remained in the position of secretary until the present
time. The association was in a position of suspended animation during the
war. Though a cup competition was carried through each year from the
beginning, no trophy materialised until after Mr. M'Dowall became secretary
for the second time. He set himself to procure a trophy worthy of the
occasion, and secured a beautifully chased article, perhaps one of the most
artistic in the hands of any minor association.
The association started with twenty-seven clubs on its
roll, and its membership soon reached the best part of the century. The idea
was this—the second elevens formed the feeders from which the first elevens
of the future must in a great measure be drawn, and it would pay to foster
them. The need of such an organisation had been long felt. It was founded to
give an impetus and interest to young players such as is engendered by cup
ties. Not very prosperous during the first five years, until in 1886-87 Mr.
M'Dowall took up the secretaryship for the second time. Careful management
and good government did the rest. If one thing conduced to the success of
the association more than another, it was the magnanimous way the committee
reinstated players who were forced to assist their first elevens during the
season. In this way Queen's Park had ten players reinstated in season
1886-87—one who had played five times; four, four times; and five, once.
With the exception of Dumbarton, who had thirteen players dealt with,
Queen's Park was most indebted to the association in this respect. The cup
was procured in this season, and duly presented to the winners—Abercorn— and
the names of the previous winners were then inscribed on the trophy—a rather
tardy honour, but none the less welcome.
Scottish Second Eleven Cup was won by Second Queen's Park
as under :—