THIS volume, of
delightful and luxurious form, is full of Scottish story. It may be
described as the happy result of the lucubrations of one of our lawyers,
the most skilled perhaps (teste the late Mr. Andrew Lang) in placing
Scottish yesterdays before us. Generally he does this with historical
subjects, but not always, otherwise we would not have had his admirable
poetic criticism (placed last in this book) on Robert Fergusson, the
Edinburgh prototype of Burns. Still, it is with historical or legal
subjects he is generally connected, at least in this collection. He
begins with ' The Riddle of the Ruthvens,' an examination of the
baffling 'Gowrie Conspiracy.' We now wonder with him whether the plot
was not as much on the King's side as on that of the victims. .Many
'trials,' judicial or else so-called, help to fill the book. We get a
magnificent view of legal Nemesis in the remote Highlands when the Pack
of the Travelling Merchant is accounted for through a dream. Witchcraft
is dealt with in three studies. Auld Auchindrayne's Murder of an
innocent boy is narrated, as is the modern case of 'Antique Smith ' who
'uttered' forgeries of the works of the great Dead some of which may
still unhappily be current. Scottish and Irish Law finds its crux in the
curious tangle of the Yelverton Marriage Case. Two important papers on
Lord Braxfield (whose portrait is twice given to show his different
aspects), soften a little his fierce contours, and one on Lord Grange,
who deported his ill-willywife to St. Kilda, are all well worth study.
It is impossible to read the book which contains many other essays of
interest without delighting in the writer's thoroughness, his knowledge
of Scottish History, his skill in unfolding the half forgotten past, and
his quaint humour.
A. FRANCIS STEUART.
You can read this book here in
pdf format |