Alexander Mackenzie's
book—Lord Selkirk interested—Emigration a
boon—Writes to Imperial Government—In 1802
looks to Lake Winnipeg—Benevolent project of
trade—Compelled to choose Prince Edward
Island—Opinions as to Hudson's Bay Company's
charter — Nor' -Westers alarmed — Hudson's
Bay Company's Stock—Purchases Assiniboia—Advertises
the new colony—Religion no
disqualification—Sends first colony—Troubles
of the project—Arrive at York Factory—The
winter—The mutiny— "Essence of Malt"—Journey
inland—A second party—Third party under
Archibald Macdonald—From Helmsdale—The
number of colonists.
The publication of his
work by Alexander Mackenzie, entitled,
"Voyages from Montreal through the Continent
of North America, &c.," awakened great
interest in the British Isles. Among those
who were much influenced by it was Thomas,
Earl of Selkirk, a young Scottish nobleman
of distinguished descent and disposition.
The young Earl at once thought of the wide
country described as a fitting home for the
poor and unsuccessful British peasantry,
who, as we learn from Wordsworth, were at
this time in a most distressful state.
During his college days
the Earl of Selkirk had often visited the
Highland glens and crofts, and though
himself a Southron, he was so interested in
his picturesque countrymen that he learned
the Gaelic language. Not only the sad
condition of Scotland, but likewise the
unsettled state of Ireland, appealed to his
heart and his patriotic sympathies. He came
to the conclusion that emigration was the
remedy for the ills of Scotland and Ireland
alike.
Accordingly we find the
energetic Earl writing to Lord Pelham to
interest the British Government in the
matter. We have before us a letter with two
memorials attached. This is dated April 4th,
1802, and was kindly supplied the writer by
the Colonial Office. The proposals, after
showing the desirability of relieving the
congested and dissatisfied population
already described, go on to speak of a
suitable field for the settlement of the
emigrants. And this we see is the region
described by Alexander Mackenzie. Lord
Selkirk says: "No large tract remains
unoccupied on the sea-coast of British
America except barren and frozen deserts. To
find a sufficient extent of good soil in a
temperate climate we must go far inland.
This inconvenience is not, however, an
insurmountable obstacle to the prosperity of
a colony, and appears to be amply
compensated by other advantages that are to
be found in some remote parts of the British
territory. At the western extremity of
Canada, upon the waters which fall into Lake
Winnipeg and which in the great river of
Port Nelson discharge themselves into Hudson
Bay, is a country which the Indian traders
represent as fertile, and of a climate far
more temperate than the shores of the
Atlantic under the same parallel, and not
more severe than that of Germany or Poland.
Here, therefore, the colonists may, with a
moderate exertion of industry, be certain of
a comfortable subsistence, and they may also
raise some valuable objects of exportation.
. . To a colony in these territories the
channel of trade must be the river of Port
Nelson."
It is exceedingly
interesting, in view of the part afterwards
played by Lord Selkirk, to read the
following statement: "The greatest
impediment to a colony in this quarter seems
to be the Hudson's Bay Company monopoly,
which the possessors cannot be expected
easily to relinquish. They may, however, be
amply indemnified for its abolition without
any burden, perhaps even with advantage to
the revenue."
The letter then goes on
to state the successful trade carried on by
the Canadian traders, and gives a scheme by
which both the Hudson's Bay Company and the
North-West Company may receive profits
greater than those then enjoyed, by a plan
of issuing licences, and limiting traders to
particular districts.
Further, the proposal
declares: "If these indefatigable Canadians
were allowed the free navigation of the
Hudson Bay they might, without going so far
from Port Nelson as they now go from
Montreal, extend their traffic from sea to
sea, through the whole northern part of
America, and send home more than double the
value that is now derived from that region."
The matter brought up
in these proposals was referred to Lord
Buckinghamshire, Colonial Secretary, but
failed for the time being, not because of
any unsuitableness of the country, but
"because the prejudices of the British
people were so strong against emigration."
During the next year Lord Selkirk succeeded
in organizing a Highland emigration of not
less than 800 souls. Not long before the
starting of the ships the British Government
seems to have interfered to prevent this
large number being led to the region of Lake
Winnipeg, and compelled Lord Selkirk to
choose the more accessible shore of Prince
Edward Island. After settling his colonists
on the island, Lord Selkirk visited
Montreal, where he was well received by the
magnates of the North-West Company, and
where his interest in the far West was
increased by witnessing, as Astor also did
about the same time, the large returns
obtained by the "lords of the lakes and
forests."
Years went past, and
Lord Selkirk, unable to obtain the assent of
the British Government to his great scheme
of colonizing the interior of North America,
at length determined to obtain possession of
the territory wanted for his plans through
the agency of the Hudson's Bay Company.
About the year 1810 he began to turn his
attention in earnest to the matter.
With characteristic
Scottish caution he submitted the charter of
the Hudson's Bay Company to the highest
legal authorities in London, including the
names Romilly, Holroyd, Cruise, Scarlett,
and John Bell. Their clear opinion was that
the Hudson's Bay Company was legally able to
sell its territory and to transfer the
numerous rights bestowed by the charter.
They say, "We are of opinion that the grant
of the soil contained in the charter is
good, and that it will include all the
country, the waters of which run into Hudson
Bay, as ascertained by geographical
observation."
Lord Selkirk, now fully
satisfied that the Hudson's Bay Company was
a satisfactory instrument, proceeded to
obtain control of the stock of the Company.
The partners of the North-West Company
learned of the steps being taken by Lord
Selkirk and became greatly alarmed. They
were of the opinion that the object of Lord
Selkirk was to make use of his great
emigration scheme to give supremacy to the
Hudson's Bay Company over its rivals, and to
injure the Nor'-Westers' fur trade. So far
as can be seen, Lord Selkirk had no interest
in the rivalry that had been going on
between the Companies for more than a
generation. His first aim was emigration,
and this for the purpose of relieving the
distress of many in the British Isles.
As showing the mind of
Lord Selkirk in the matter we have before us
a copy of his lordship's work on emigration
published in 1805. This copy is a gift to
the writer from Lady Isabella Hope, the late
daughter of Lord Selkirk. In this octavo
volume, upwards of 280 pages, the whole
question of the state of the Highlands is
ably described. Tracing the condition of the
Highlanders from the Rebellion of 1745, and
the necessity of emigration, Lord Selkirk
refers to the demand for keeping up the
Highland regiments as being less than
formerly, and that the Highland proprietors
had been opposed to emigration*.
His patriotism was also
stirred in favour of preventing the flow of
British subjects to the United States, and
in his desire to see the British
possessions, especially in America, filled
up with loyal British subjects. Ho states
that in his Prince Edward Island Company in
1803 he had succeeded in securing a number
from the Isle of Skye, whose friends had
largely gone to North Carolina, and that
others of them were from Ross, Argyle, and
Inverness, and that the friends of these had
chiefly gone to the United States.
After going into some
detail as to the management of his Prince
Edward Island Highlanders, ho speaks of the
success of his experiment, and gives us
proof of his consuming interest in the
progress and happiness of his poor
fellow-countrymen. It is consequently almost
beyond doubt the fact that it was his desire
for carrying out his emigration scheme that
led him to obtain control of the Hudson's
Bay Company, and not the desire to introduce
a colony to injure the North-West trade, as
charged.
There can be no doubt
of Lord Selkirk's thoroughly patriotic and
lofty aims. In 1808 he published a brochure
of some eighty pages on "A System of
National Defence." In this he shows the
value of a local militia and proposes a plan
for the maintenance of a sufficient force to
protect Great Britain from its active enemy,
Napoleon. He maintains that a Volunteer
force would not be permanent; and that under
any semblance of peace that establishment
must immediately fall to pieces. His only
dependence for the safety of the country is
in a local militia.
With his plan somewhat
matured, he continued in 1810 to obtain
possession of stock of the Company, and
succeeded in having much of it in the hands
of his friends. By May, 1811, he had with
his friends acquired, it is said, not less
than 35,000l. of the total stock, 105,000/.
sterling. A general court of the proprietors
was called for May 30th, and the proposition
was made by Lord Selkirk to purchase a tract
of land lying in the wide expanse of
Rupert's Land and on the Red River of the
North, to settle, within a limited time, a
large colony on their lands and to assume
the expense of transport, of outlay for the
settlers, of government, of protection, and
of quieting the Indian title to the lands.
At the meeting there was represented about
45,000l. worth of stock, and the vote on
being taken showed the representatives of
nearly 30,000l. of the stock to be in favour
of accepting Lord Selkirk's proposal. Among
those who voted with the enterprising Earl
were his kinsmen, Andrew Wedderburn, Esq.
(having nearly 4,500l. stock), William
Mainwaring, the Governor Joseph Berens,
Deputy-Governor John Henry Pelly, and many
other well-known proprietors.
The opposition was,
however, by no means insignificant, William
Thwaytes, representing nearly 10,000l.,
voted against the proposal, as did also
Robert Whitehead, who held 3,000l. stock.
The most violent opponents, however, were
the Nor'-Westers who were in England at the
time. Two of them had only purchased stock
within forty-eight hours of the meeting.
These were Alexander Mackenzie, John Inglis,
and Edward Ellice, the three together
representing less than 2,500l.
The projector of the
colony having now beaten down all
opposition, forthwith proceeded to carry out
his great plan of colonization. His project
has, of course, been greatly criticized. He
has been called "a kind-hearted but
visionary Scottish nobleman," and his
relative, Sir James Wedderbum, spoke of him
fifty years afterwards as "a remarkable man,
who had the misfortune to live before his
time." Certainly Lord Selkirk met with
gigantic difficulties, but these were rather
from the North-West Company than from any
untime-liness in his emigration scheme.
Lord Selkirk soon
issued the advertisement and prospectus of
the new colony. He held forth the advantage
to be derived from joining the colony. His
policy was very comprehensive. He said: "The
settlement is to be formed in a territory
where religion is not the ground of any
disqualification; an unreserved
participation in every privilege will
therefore be enjoyed by Protestant and
Catholic without distinction."
The area of the new
settlement was said to consist of 110,000
square miles on the Red and Assiniboine
Rivers, and one of the most fertile
districts of North America. The name
Assiniboia was given it from the
Assiniboine, and steps were taken
immediately to organize a government for the
embryo colony.
Active measures were
then taken by the Earl of Selkirk to advance
his scheme, and it was determined to send
out the first colony immediately. Some years
before, Lord Selkirk had carried on a
correspondence with a U. E. Loyalist
colonist, Miles Macdonell, formerly an
officer of the King's Royal Regiment of New
York, who had been given the rank of captain
in the Canadian Militia. Macdonell's
assistance was obtained in the new
enterprise, and he was appointed by his
lordship to superintend his colony at Red
River.
Many incorrect
statements have been made about the
different bands of colonists which found
their way to Red River. No loss than four
parties arrived at Red River by way of York
or Churchill Factories between the years
1811 and 1815. Facts connected with one of
them have been naturally confused in the
memories of the old settlers on Red River
with what happened to other bands. In this
way the author has found that
representations made to him and embodied in
his work on "Manitoba," published in 1882,
were in several particulars incorrect.
Fortunately in late years the letter-book of
Captain Miles Macdonell was acquired from
the Misses Macdonell of Brockville, and the
voluminous correspondence of Lord Selkirk
has been largely copied for the Archives at
Ottawa. These letters enable us to give a
clear and accurate account of the first band
of colonists that found its way to the heart
of the Continent and began the Red River
settlement.
In the end of June,
1811, Captain Miles Macdonell found himself
at Yarmouth, on the east coast of England,
with a fleet of three vessels sent out by
the Hudson's Bay Company for their regular
trade and also to carry the first colonists.
These vessels were the Prince of Wales, the
Eddystone, and an old craft the Edward and
Anne, with "old sail ropes, &c, and very
badly manned." This extra vessel was
evidently intended for the accommodation of
the colonists. By the middle of July the
little fleet had reached the Pentland Firth
and were compelled to put into Stromness,
when the Prince of Wales embarked a number
of Orkneymen intended for the Company's
service. The men of the Hudson's Bay Company
at this time were largely drawn from the
Orkney Islands.
Proceeding on their way
the fleet made rendezvous at Stornoway, the
chief town of Lewis, one of the Hebrides.
Here had arrived a number of colonists or
employes, some from Sligo, others from
Glasgow, and others from different parts of
the Highlands. Many influences were
operating against the success of the
colonizing expedition. It had the strenuous
opposition of Sir Alexander Mackenzie, then
in Britain, and the newspapers contained
articles intended to discourage and dissuade
people from embarking in the enterprise. Mr.
Reid, collector of Customs at Stornoway,
whose wife was an aunt of Sir Alexander
Mackenzie, threw every impediment in the way
of the project, and some of those engaged by
Lord Selkirk were actually lured away by
enlisting agents. A so-called "Captain "
Mackenzie, denominated a "mean fellow," came
alongside the Edward and Anne, which had
some seventy-six men aboard—Glasgow men,
Irish, "and a few from Orkney"— and claimed
some of them as "deserters from Her
Majesty's service." The demand was, however,
resisted. It is no wonder that in his letter
to Lord Selkirk Captain Macdonell writes,
"All the men that we shall have are now
embarked, but it has been an herculean
task."
A prominent employ of
the expedition, Mr. Moncrieff Blair, posing
as a gentleman, deserted on July 25th, the
day before the sailing of the vessels. A
number of the deserters at Stornoway had
left their effects on board, and these were
disposed of by sale among the passengers.
Among the officers was a Mr. Edwards, who
acted as medical man of the expedition. He
had his hands completely full during the
voyage and returned to England with the
ships. Another notable person on board was a
Roman Catholic priest, known as Father
Bourke. Captain Macdonell was himself a
Roman Catholic, but he seems from the first
to have had no confidence in the priest,
who, he stated, had "come away without the
leave of his bishop, who was at the time at
Dublin." Father Bourke, we shall see, though
carried safely to the shores of Hudson Bay,
never reached the interior, but returned to
Britain in the following year. After the
usual incidents of "an uncommon share of
boisterous, stormy, and cold weather" on the
ocean, the ships entered Hudson Bay.
Experiencing "a course of fine mild weather
and moderate fair winds," on September 24th
the fleet reached the harbour of York
Factory, after a voyage of sixty-one days
out from Stornoway, the Eddystonc, which was
intended to go to Churchill, not having been
able to reach that Factory, coming with the
other vessels to York Factory.
The late arrival of the
colony on the shores of Hudson Bay made it
impossible to ascend the Nelson River and
roach the interior during the season of
1811. Accordingly Captain Macdonell made
preparations for wintering on the Bay. York
Factory would not probably have afforded
sufficient accommodation for the colonists,
but in addition Captain Macdonell states in
a letter to Lord Selkirk that "the factory
is very ill constructed and not at all
adapted for a cold country." In consequence
of these considerations, Captain Macdonell
at once undertook, during the fair weather
of the season yet remaining, to build winter
quarters on the north side of the river, at
a distance of some miles from the Factory.
No doubt matters of discipline entered into
the plans of the leader of the colonists. In
a short time very comfortable dwellings were
erected, built of round logs, the front side
high with a shade roof sloping to the rear a
foot thick—and the group of huts was known
as "Nelson encampment!"
The chief work during
the earlier winter, which the captain laid
on his two score men, was providing
themselves with fuel, of which there was
plenty, and obtaining food from the Factory,
for which sledges drawn over the snow were
utilized by the detachments sent on this
service. The most serious difficulty was,
however, a meeting, in which a dozen or more
of the men became completely insubordinate,
and refused to yield obedience either to
Captain Macdonell or to Mr. W. H. Cook, the
Governor of the Factory. Every effort was
made to maintain discipline, but the men
steadily held to their own way, lived apart
from Macdonell, and drew their own
provisions from the fort to their huts. This
tended to make the winter somewhat long and
disagreeable.
Captain Macdonell,
being a Canadian, knew well the dangers of
the dread disease of the scurvy attacking
his inexperienced colonists. The men at the
fort prophesied evil things in this respect
for the "encampment." The captain took early
steps to meet the disease, and his letters
to Governor Cook always contain demands for
"essence of malt," "crystallized salts of
lemon," and other anti-scorbutics. Though
some of his men were attacked, yet the
sovereign remedy so often employed in the
"lumber camps" of America, the Juice of the
white spruce, was applied with almost
magical effect. As the winter went on,
plenty of venison was received, and the
health of his wintering party was in the
spring much better than could have been
anticipated.
After the New Year had
come, all thoughts were directed to
preparations for the Journey of 700 miles or
thereabouts to the interior. A number of
boats were required for transportation of
the colonists and their effects. Captain
Macdonell insisted on his boats being made
after a different style from the boats
commonly used at that time by the Company.
His model was the flat boat, which he had
seen used in the Mohawk River in the State
of New York, The workmanship displayed in
the making of these boats very much
dissatisfied Captain Macdonell, and he
constantly complained of the indolence of
the workmen. In consequence of this
inefficiency the cost of the boats to Lord
Selkirk was very great, and drew forth the
objections of the leader of the colony.
Captain Macdonell had
the active assistance of Mr. Cook, the
officer in charge of York, and of Mr. Auld,
the Commander of Churchill, the latter
having come down to York to make
arrangements for the inland journey of the
colonists. By July 1st, 1812, the ice had
moved from the river, and the ex-pedition
started soon after on the Journey to Red
River. The new settlers found the route a
hard and trying one with its rapids and
portages. The boats, too, were heavy, and
the colonists inexperienced in managing
them. It was well on toward autumn when the
company, numbering about seventy, reached
the Red River. No special preparation had
been made for the colonists, and the winter
would soon be upon them. Some of the parties
were given shelter in the Company fort and
buildings, others in the huts of the freed
men, who were married to the Indian women,
and settled in the neighbourhood of the
Forks, while others still found refuge in
the tents of the Indian encampment in the
vicinity. Governor Macdonell soon selected
Point Douglas as the future centre of the
colony and what is now Kildonan as the
settlement. On account of the want of food
the settlers were taken sixty miles south to
Pembina and there, by November, a post,
called Fort Daer from one of Lord Selkirk's
titles, was erected for the shelter of the
people and for nearness to the buffalo
herds. The Governor Joined the colony in a
short time and retired with them early in
1813 to their settlement.
While Governor
Macdonell was thus early engaged in making a
beginning in the new colony, Lord Selkirk
was seeking out more colonists, and sent out
a small number to the New World by the
Hudson's Bay Company ships. Before sailing
from Stornoway the second party met with
serious interruption from the collector of
Customs, who, we have seen, was related to
Sir Alexander Mackenzie. The number on board
the ships was greater, it was claimed, than
the "Dundas Act" permitted. Through the
influence of Lord Selkirk the ships were
allowed to proceed on their voyage. Prison
fever, it is said, broke out on the voyage,
so that a number died at sea, and others on
the shore of Hudson Bay. A small number, not
more than fifteen or twenty, reached Red
River in the autumn of 1813.
During the previous
winter Governor Macdonell had taken a number
of the colonists to Pembina, a point sixty
miles south of the Forks, where buffalo
could be had, as has already been mentioned
on the previous page. On returning, after
the second winter, to the settlement, the
colonists sowed a small quantity of wheat.
They were not, however, at that time in
possession of any horses or oxen and were
consequently compelled to prepare the ground
with the hoe.
Lord Selkirk had not
been anxious in 1812 to send a large
addition to his colony. In 1813 he made
greater efforts, and in June sent out in the
Prince of Wales, sailing from Orkney, a
party under Mr. Archibald Macdonald,
numbering some ninety-three persons. Mr.
Macdonald has written an account of his
voyage, and has given us a remarkably
concise and clear pamphlet. Having spent the
winter at Churchill, Macdonald started on
April 14th with a considerable number of his
party, and, coming by way of York Factory,
reached Red River on June 22nd, when they
were able to plant some thirty or forty
bushels of potatoes. The settlers were in
good spirits, having received plots of land
to build houses for themselves. Governor
Macdonell went northward to meet the
remainder of Archibald Macdonald's party,
and arrived with them late in the season.
On account of various
misunderstandings between the colony and the
North-West Company, which we shall relate
more particularly in another chapter, 150 of
the colonists were induced by a North-West
officer, Duncan Cameron, to leave the
country and go by a long canoe journey to
Canada. The remainder, numbering about sixty
persons, making up about thirteen families,
were driven from the settlement, and found
refuge at Norway House (Jack River) at the
foot of Lake Winnipeg. An officer from Lord
Selkirk, Colin Robertson, arrived in the
colony to assist these settlers, but found
them driven out. He followed them to Norway
House, and with his twenty clerks and
servants, conducted them back to Red River
to their deserted homes.
While these disastrous
proceedings were taking place on Red River,
including the summons to Governor Macdonell
to appear before the Courts of Lower Canada
to answer certain charges made against him,
Lord Selkirk was especially active in Great
Britain, and gathered together the best band
of settlers yet sent out. These were largely
from the parish of Kildonan, in
Sutherlandshire, Scotland. Governor
Macdonell having gone east to Canada, the
colony was to be placed under a new
Governor, a military officer of some
distinction, Robert Semple, who had
travelled in different parts of the world.
Governor Semple was in charge of this fourth
party of colonists, who numbered about 100.
With this party, hastening through his
journey, Governor Semple reached his
destination on Red River in the month of
October, in the same year in which they had
left the motherland.
Thus we have seen the
arrival of those who were known as the
Selkirk colonists. We recapitulate their
numbers :—
In 1811, reaching Red
River in 1812..... 70
In 1812, reaching
Red River in 1813.....15 or 20
In 1813,
reaching Red River in two parties in 1814 .
. 93
In 1815, reaching Red River in the
same year . . . 100
Making deduction of
the Irish settlers there were of the
Highland colonists about....... 270
Less
those led by the North-West Company in 1814
to Canada........ 140
Permanent Highland
settlers ...... 130
Of these but two
remained on the banks of the Red River in
1897, George Bannerman and John Matheson,
and they have both died since that time.
We shall follow the
history of these colonists further; suffice
it now to say that their settlement has
proved the country to be one of great
fertility and promise; and their early
establishment no doubt prevented
international complications with the United
States that might have rendered the
possession of Rupert's Land a matter of
uncertainty to Great Britain.